Agenda - Heritage Advisory Committee - 20230731Town of Aurora
Heritage Advisory Committee
Meeting Agenda
Date:Monday, July 31, 2023
Time:7 p.m.
Location:Holland Room, Aurora Town Hall
Meetings are available to the public in person and via live stream on the Town’s YouTube channel.
To participate, please visit aurora.ca/participation.
Pages
1.Call to Order
2.Land Acknowledgement
3.Approval of the Agenda
4.Declarations of Pecuniary Interest and General Nature Thereof
5.Receipt of the Minutes
5.1 Heritage Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes of May 1, 2023 1
That the Heritage Advisory Committee meeting minutes of May
1, 2023, be received for information.
1.
6.Delegations
7.Matters for Consideration
7.1 Memorandum from Senior Planner; Re: Development Application Review
– 16, 20 and 22 Allaura Boulevard
6
That the memorandum regarding Development Application
Review - 16, 20 and 22 Allaura Boulevard be received; and
1.
That the Heritage Advisory Committee comments be received
and referred to staff for consideration and further action as
appropriate.
2.
7.2 Memorandum from Senior Planner; Re: Status of 287 Properties
Recommended to Remain Listed on the Town’s Heritage Register
13
That the memorandum regarding Status of 287 Properties
Recommended to Remain Listed on the Town’s Heritage
Register be received; and
1.
That the Heritage Advisory Committee comments be received
and referred to staff for consideration and further action as
appropriate.
2.
8.Informational Items
9.New Business
10.Adjournment
Town of Aurora
Heritage Advisory Committee
Meeting Minutes
Date:
Time:
Location:
Monday, May 1, 2023
7 p.m.
Holland Room, Aurora Town Hall
Committee Members: Councillor John Gallo (Chair)
Cynthia Bettio
David Heard
Kevin Hughes*
John Green
Jeff Lanthier (Vice Chair)*
Bob McRoberts
Other Attendees: Councillor Ron Weese*
Adam Robb, Senior Planner, Development/Heritage
Linda Bottos, Council/Committee Coordinator
*Attended electronically
_____________________________________________________________________
1. Call to Order
The Chair called the meeting to order at 7 p.m.
Introductions were made around the table.
1.1 Appointment of Committee Vice Chair
Moved by John Green
Seconded by Bob McRoberts
1. That Jeff Lanthier be elected as Vice Chair of the Heritage Advisory
Committee for a two-year term (2023-2024).
Carried
Page 1 of 302
Heritage Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes
Monday, May 1, 2023 2
2. Land Acknowledgement
The Committee acknowledged that the meeting took place on Anishinaabe lands,
the traditional and treaty territory of the Chippewas of Georgina Island,
recognizing the many other Nations whose presence here continues to this day,
the special relationship the Chippewas have with the lands and waters of this
territory, and that Aurora has shared responsibility for the stewardship of these
lands and waters. It was noted that Aurora is part of the treaty lands of the
Mississaugas and Chippewas, recognized through Treaty #13 and the Williams
Treaties of 1923.
3. Approval of the Agenda
Moved by David Heard
Seconded by Bob McRoberts
That the agenda as circulated by Legislative Services be approved.
Carried
4. Declarations of Pecuniary Interest and General Nature Thereof
There were no declarations of pecuniary interest under the Municipal Conflict of
Interest Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. M.50.
5. Receipt of the Minutes
None.
6. Delegations
None.
7. Matters for Consideration
7.1 Memorandum from Senior Planner; Re: Heritage Permit Application File:
HPA-2023-04, 19 Catherine Avenue
Peter Hillar, President/CEO of Greyfield Construction Co. Ltd., presented
an overview of the application including depictions of the proposed
Page 2 of 302
Heritage Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes
Monday, May 1, 2023 3
demolition, two-storey rear yard addition, and exterior materials. Staff
provided further comment and acknowledged that effort had been made
to respect compatibility and noted the main elements for consideration
and input from the Committee including feedback on the westerly balcony
component, chimney location, and general massing.
The Committee discussed and inquired about various aspects including
the increased footprint size, feedback from neighbours, and other rear
additions on the street. The Committee expressed support for the
application as presented.
Moved by Jeff Lanthier
Seconded by John Green
1. That the memorandum regarding Heritage Permit Application File:
HPA-2023-04, 19 Catherine Avenue, be received; and
2. That the Heritage Advisory Committee comments regarding Heritage
Permit Application File: HPA-2023-04, 19 Catherine Avenue, be
received and referred to staff for consideration and further action as
appropriate.
Carried
7.2 Memorandum from Senior Planner; Re: Request to Remove 28 Wells Street
from the Aurora Register of Properties of Cultural Heritage Value or Interest
Paul Oberst, Heritage Consultant and Architect, presented an overview of
the heritage evaluation of the property at 28 Wells Street, including a
review of the criteria ratings under Ontario Regulation 9/06, and
conceptual elevations of the proposed replacement buildings. Staff
provided further comment on the property’s heritage value and noted the
impact of Provincial Bill 23 on the heritage planning process.
The Committee discussed and inquired about various aspects including
designation priorities, previous ownership and significance, the previous
evaluation process versus new regulations and criteria, and the potential
to fully restore the building or incorporate the existing building/facade
with a rear addition. The Committee did not support the removal of 28
Wells Street from the Heritage Register.
Page 3 of 302
Heritage Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes
Monday, May 1, 2023 4
Staff agreed to have the owner conduct a title search and research the
previous ownership of the property to determine any potential
significance.
Moved by David Heard
Seconded by Bob McRoberts
1. That the memorandum regarding Request to Remove 28 Wells Street
from the Aurora Register of Properties of Cultural Heritage Value or
Interest be received; and
2. That the Heritage Advisory Committee comments regarding Request
to Remove 28 Wells Street from the Aurora Register of Properties of
Cultural Heritage Value or Interest be received and referred to staff for
consideration and further action as appropriate.
Carried
8. Informational Items
None.
9. New Business
The Committee expressed concerns regarding the impact of Provincial Bill 23
and the remaining 287 properties on the Heritage Register that may be worthy of
designation, which need to be addressed by January 1, 2025. It was suggested
that members would benefit by guidance on how to use the new criteria under
Ontario Regulation 9/06. Staff agreed to bring this item forward for discussion
and prioritization at the next meeting.
Committee members recommended that the Committee meet on a monthly
basis and requested that the Terms of Reference be revised accordingly.
The Committee referred to the Town’s newly renovated train station and noted
the wood plaque is faded and should be refreshed or replaced. It was further
suggested that other wood plaques be reviewed and addressed as necessary.
Staff noted that wood plaques are available and can be prepared for properties
as needed.
Page 4 of 302
Heritage Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes
Monday, May 1, 2023 5
Committee members expressed concerns about the purpose and value of the
Committee under the current format of providing only comments instead of
making recommendations for Council’s consideration as done in previous terms
of Council.
The Committee discussed potential ideas and events toward the promotion of
heritage, increased community awareness, education, and youth engagement.
10. Adjournment
Moved by Cynthia Bettio
Seconded by Kevin Hughes
That the meeting be adjourned at 8:36 p.m.
Carried
Page 5 of 302
100 John West Way
Aurora, Ontario
L4G 6J1
(905) 727-3123
aurora.ca
Town of Aurora
Memorandum
Planning and Development Services
Re: Development Application Review – 16, 20 and 22 Allaura Boulevard
To: Heritage Advisory Committee
From: Adam Robb, MPL, MCIP, RPP, CAHP, Senior Planner
Date: July 31, 2023
Recommendation
1. That the memorandum regarding Development Application Review – 16, 20 and 22
Allaura Boulevard be received; and
2. That the Heritage Advisory Committee comments be received and referred to staff
for consideration and further action as appropriate.
Background
The proposal at 16, 20 and 22 Allaura Boulevard is to facilitate the development of 225
stacked townhouses on the north side of Allaura Boulevard, east of Yonge Street. The
owner has applied for a Zoning By-law Amendment (ZBA-2022-08), Plan of Subdivision
(SUB-2022-02), and Site Plan (SP-2022-13) application to enable the residential built
form as part of the Aurora Promenade area. The proposal also features an internal road
network as well as underground parking.
This is the first submission for the proposal, with a detailed review by Town
departments and external agencies still ongoing. The proposal will also be subject to a
future public planning meeting prior to any decision being made.
Analysis
The designated Aurora War Memorial Peace Park is adjacent to the subject lands
The Aurora War Memorial Peace Park was designated under Part IV of the Ontario
Heritage Act in 2008 (By-law No. 4977-07) and is located to the northwest and adjacent
to the subject property. The designation by-law for the Aurora War Memorial Peace Park
specifically states that protected heritage elements include the cenotaph, altar of
Page 6 of 302
Development Application Review – 16, 20 and 22 Allaura Boulevard
July 31, 2023 Page 2 of 2
sacrifice, flag poles, granite stairs to the monument, and general park landscape
including the mature trees.
In line with the goals of the Town’s Official Plan, all development shall be sympathetic
to the cultural heritage resources of the community. It is a priority to ensure that
development, including development on adjacent parcels, respects the heritage
character and attributes of surrounding properties and the area at large.
Comments received from the Heritage Advisory Committee can be used to inform design
revisions as part of the development application review process
As part of the initial staff review, comments on the development proposal include the
following:
Ensuring all vistas and sightlines to the Aurora War Memorial Peace Park are
maintained, protected, and enhanced.
Revising the layout of the proposed development to potentially enable pedestrian
connection to the Aurora War Memorial Peace Park, which would create an
additional opportunity to access the Park not just from Yonge Street.
Encouraging more opportunities for transitional open space or naturalized area
leading to/from the Park and any potential connections to it.
Relocating the waste pickup location further from the Aurora War Memorial
Peace Park.
Any additional comments received from the Heritage Advisory Committee will also be
used to inform further revisions or design considerations for the development.
Attachments
Attachment 1 – Site Plan and Drawings
Page 7 of 302
Attachment 1
Page 8 of 302
STREET 'B'STREET 'A'
STREET 'A
'
STREET 'A'1.50 m. SIDEWALK1.50 m. SIDEWALK1.50 m. SID
E
W
A
L
K
1.50 m. SIDE
W
A
L
K
CROSSWALKLOT BOUND
A
R
YLOT BOUNDARY1.50 m. SIDE
W
A
L
K
1.50 m. SIDE
W
A
L
KRAMP DOWNWASTE Open SpaceLandscaped courtyardLandscaped 406.87 sq mCROSSWALKCROSSWALKCROSSWALK MUNICIPAL SIDEWALKMUNICIPAL SIDEWALK18 UNITS
3.5 STOREY
S
T
A
C
K
E
D
BUILDING
#
8
16 UNITS
3.5 STORE
Y
S
T
A
C
K
E
D
BUILDING
#
9
UPUPUP
UP UPUPUPUP16 UNITS
3.5 STORE
Y
S
T
A
C
K
E
D
BUILDING
#
1
0
UPUPUP
UP UPUPUPUP3.5 STOREY STACKED16 UNITSBUILDING #1UPUPUPUPUPUPUPUP3.5 STOREY STACKED32 UNITSBUILDING #23.5 STOREY STACKED28 UNITSBUILDING #426 UNITS3.5 STORE
Y
S
T
A
C
K
E
D
BUILDING #
33.5 STOREY STACKED25 UNITSBUILDING #53.5 STOREY STACKED30 UNITSBUILDING #6UP UPUPUP
UPUPUPUP18 UNITS3.5 STOREY STACKED
BUILDING #7 Courtyard CROSSW
A
L
K
CROSSWA
L
K
1.50 m.
SI
D
E
W
A
L
K
1.50 m.
SI
D
E
W
A
L
K
1.50 m. SIDEWALK1.50 m. SIDEWALK1.50 m. SIDEWALK1.50 m. SIDEWALK1.50 m. SIDEWALKMUNICIPAL SIDEWALK1.50 m. SIDE
W
A
L
K52.04m FIRE ACCESStͲϮϱϵϬ;EKs D ZϮϰ͕ϮϬϮϮͿ>>hZ>/D/d WZdE Z^,/WϮϰϴ< EE z^dZ dt ^dϭϲ͕ϮϬ͕ϮϮ>>hZ>s͘hZKZ͕KE>ϰ'ϲ^ϰ^/d W>EͲϬϭZ s/^/KE ^h: d d ^> ͗ϭ͗Ϭ͘ϲZ>/D/d WZdE Z^,/WEE z^dZ dt ^dϬ͕ϮϮ>>hZ>s͘KE>ϰ'ϲ^ϰtͲϮϱϵϬhZKZ^/d WͲϬϭ>>hZϮϰϴ< Eϭϲ͕ϮϬhZKZEKd/^^h &KZKE^dZhd/KEPage 9 of 302
W
D
FURNACEBEDROOM 28'8" X 11'2"MASTER BEDROOM10'2" X 14'8"MASTERENSUITEMAINBATH RM.LNDRY.KITCHEN7'2 X 8'10"LIVING/DININGROOM11'0" X 18'0"FOYERBALCONY9'6" X 6'0"BALCONY ABOVEHWTFOYERUPW
DFURNACE UPBEDROOM 28'8" X 11'2"MASTER BEDROOM10'2" X 14'8"MASTERENSUITEMAINBATH RM.LNDRY.KITCHEN7'2 X 8'10"LIVING/DININGROOM11'0" X 18'0"FOYERBALCONY9'6" X 6'0"BALCONY ABOVEHWTFOYERUPUPUPUPUPUPW
DFURNACE
BEDROOM 28'8" X 11'2"MASTER BEDROOM10'2" X 14'8"MASTERENSUITEMAINBATH RM.LNDRY.KITCHEN7'2 X 8'10"LIVING/DININGROOM11'0" X 18'0"FOYERBALCONY9'6" X 6'0"BALCONY ABOVEHWTFOYERUPW
D
FURNACEUPBEDROOM 28'8" X 11'2"MASTER BEDROOM10'2" X 14'8"MASTERENSUITEMAINBATH RM.LNDRY.KITCHEN7'2 X 8'10"LIVING/DININGROOM11'0" X 18'0"FOYERBALCONY9'6" X 6'0"BALCONY ABOVEHWTFOYERUPUPUPUPUPUPtͲϮϱϵϬ;EKs D ZϮϰ͕ϮϬϮϮͿ>>hZ>/D/d WZdE Z^,/WϮϰϴ< EE z^dZ dt ^dϭϲ͕ϮϬ͕ϮϮ>>hZ>s͘hZKZ͕KE>ϰ'ϲ^ϰͲϬϰ^> ͗ϭ͗ϭϬϬϬZ>/D/d WZdE Z^,/WEE z^dZ dt ^dϬ͕ϮϮ>>hZ>s͘ KE >ϰ' ϲ^ϰtͲϮϱϵϬhZKZͲϬϰ>>hZϮϰϴ< Eϭϲ͕ϮϬhZKZZ s/^/KE ^h: d d EKd/^^h &KZKE^dZhd/KE>K<W>EE > sd/KE^h/>/E'ϭ͕ϳ͕ϴ͕ϵ͕ϭϬPage 10 of 302
Page 11 of 302
Page 12 of 302
100 John West Way
Aurora, Ontario
L4G 6J1
(905) 727-3123
aurora.ca
Town of Aurora
Memorandum
Planning and Development Services
Re: Status of 287 Properties Recommended to Remain Listed on the Town’s
Heritage Register
To: Heritage Advisory Committee
From: Adam Robb, MPL, MCIP, RPP, CAHP, Senior Planner
Date: July 31, 2023
Recommendation
1. That the memorandum regarding Status of 287 Properties Recommended to Remain
Listed on the Town’s Heritage Register be received; and
2. That the Heritage Advisory Committee comments be received and referred to staff
for consideration and further action as appropriate.
Background
In 2021, the Town retained MHBC Planning Inc. to conduct a Heritage Register Review
The Heritage Register Review project was completed in 2022 and evaluated the 374
properties on the Town’s Heritage Register to determine which should be prioritized for
designation, be removed, or remain as listed. Alongside consultation with the Heritage
Advisory Committee, 30 properties were prioritized for designation, 57 properties were
removed, and 287 currently remain as listed. The Heritage Register Review project also
recommended that in the course of time, other warranted listed properties also be
advanced towards designation.
Analysis
As a result of Provincial Bill 23, all listed properties in Ontario will be removed from
municipal Heritage Registers on January 1, 2025, unless they are designated
Bill 23 was introduced by the Province as a means to expedite the planning and
approval process and encourage the delivery of housing opportunities across Ontario.
The omnibus legislation has resulted in changes to the Ontario Heritage Act wherein
Page 13 of 302
Status of 287 Properties Recommended to Remain Listed
July 31, 2023 Page 2 of 3
listed properties are to be automatically removed from municipal Heritage Registers
effective January 1, 2025. The resulting impact is that the Province no longer wants
properties to remain as listed for extended periods of time, and as such, the ability to
“list” properties will be greatly reduced. All currently listed properties will be removed on
January 1, 2025, and cannot be re-listed again for another five (5) years. If re-listed, they
would then be subject to removal again after two (2) years, if not designated within that
time.
The Heritage Register Review already resulted in the designation effort of 30 priority
properties in Town. However, with the recent legislative changes and the January 1,
2025, deadline, additional listed properties can be considered for designation prior to
their automatic removal.
Two of nine criteria under Ontario Regulation 9/06 need to be met to qualify for
designation
The Ontario Heritage Act provides criteria for determining cultural heritage value or
interest through Ontario Regulation 9/06. This Regulation requires that a building must
exhibit design/physical, historical/associative, or contextual value to warrant
designation. In order to qualify for designation, a property must substantially meet two
(2) of the nine (9) criteria. The criteria under Ontario Regulation 9/06 are as follows:
Design or
Physical Value
1. Property is a rare, unique, representative or early example of a
style, expression, material or construction method.
2. Property displays a high degree of craftmanship or artistic merit.
3. Property demonstrates a high degree of technical or scientific
achievement.
Historical or
Associative
Value
4. Property has direct associations with a theme, event, belief,
person, activity, organization or institution that is significant to
the community.
5. Property yields, or has the potential to yield, information that
contributes to an understanding of a community or culture.
6. Property reflects the work or ideas of an architect, artist, builder,
designer or theorist who is significant to a community.
Page 14 of 302
Status of 287 Properties Recommended to Remain Listed
July 31, 2023 Page 3 of 3
Contextual
Value
7. Property is important in defining, maintaining, or supporting the
character of an area.
8. Property is physically, functionally, visually or historically linked to
its surroundings.
9. Property is a landmark.
Additionally, through recent provincial legislative updates, properties being pursued for
designation can also now be appealed by the owners to the Ontario Land Tribunal, and
there are opportunities available to property owners to object to the designation of their
property before Council.
Some, but not all, of the remaining listed properties on the Town’s Heritage Register meet
the criteria to be designated
Based on Ontario Regulation 9/06 and the evaluations conducted as part of the
Heritage Register Review (attached), staff are of the opinion that the following
remaining listed properties would generally satisfy Ontario Regulation 9/06 and meet
the required criteria for designation:
Kennedy Street West – 7, 11, 15, 19, 21, 29
Spruce Street – 76, 77, 79, 80, 81, 83, 84 85, 87
Temperance Street – 126, 134, 137, 138, 139, 142, 143
59 Tyler Street
Wellington Street East - 9, 21
19, 35 and 37 Wellington Street West (one parcel)
Yonge Street – 15018, 15120, 15054
This report also seeks additional input and comment from the Heritage Advisory
Committee, with further action to then be taken by staff, including on potential
consultation and outreach with the owners, pending Council direction.
Attachments
Attachment 1 – Heritage Register Review Property Sheets
Page 15 of 302
Yonge Street
Catherine
Avenue
Machell Avenue
Irwin
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 15 Irwin Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Plan 36
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1883
Date Identified/Listed: 1986
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes: Stucco likely a later addition - appears to be in
poor condition.
Risk: No
Risk Notes: Removal of original features and materials results in
compromised integrity. No longer a good representative example of
a Victorian dwelling.
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 36, registered by
Richard Wells and dwellings constructed shortly after the time Plan 36
was registered in the late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Built by William Sweezy
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Machell/Irwin
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
$WWDFKPHQW
Attachment 1 Page 16 of 302
YongeStreetMachell AvenueIrwin Av
e
n
u
e
Address: 17 Irwin Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 10 Plan 36
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1865
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Gable. Originally located on Orchard
Heights Blvd and was moved in the 1900's. "Historical Society file
indicates that a Mr Norman Scott said this house was moved to this
location from a site near the reservoir on Orchard Heights Blvd in the
early 1900's. The Scott family purchased the structure at that location
and then had it moved to its present location."
Condition Notes: Rear brick addition. Front verandah shortened.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
None
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Machell/Irwin
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1860s
Page 17 of 302
Machell AvenueIrwin Av
e
n
u
e
Address: 21 Irwin Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 10 Plan 36
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1875
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Ontario Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Pediment, centre gable with window
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 36, registered by
Richard Wells and dwellings constructed shortly after the time Plan 36
was registered in the late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Machell/Irwin
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 18 of 302
Yonge StreetCatherine
AvenueMachellAvenueIrwin Av
e
n
u
e
Address: 8 Irwin Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 14 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1920
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Vernacular (Aurora)
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Pediment, dormer, gable
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 36, registered by
Richard Wells and dwellings constructed shortly after the time Plan 36
was registered in the late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Machell/Irwin
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 19 of 302
Alex
G
a
r
d
n
e
r
C ircl e
Wellingto
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
tMachell AvenueAddress: 11 Machell Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 3 Plan 36
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1915
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling and Outbuilding
Heritage Attributes Notes: Barn interior to the property, behind the
house.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 36, registered by
Richard Wells and dwellings constructed shortly after the time Plan 36
was registered in the late 19th century.
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Machell/Irwin
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 20 of 302
Machell AvenueA lex
G
a
r
d
n
e
r
C
i
r
c
l e
Address: 31 Machell Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 8 Plan 36
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1870
Date Identified/Listed: 1986
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Front gable, Verandah along front
elevation
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 36, registered by
Richard Wells and dwellings constructed shortly after the time Plan 36
was registered in the late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Machell/Irwin
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 21 of 302
Machell AvenueA le x
G
a
r
d
n
e
r
C
i
r
c
l
e
Irwin
Avenue
Address: 35 Machell Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 9 Plan 36
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1886
Date Identified/Listed: 1986
Architectural Style/Influence: Georgian
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 36, registered by
Richard Wells and dwellings constructed shortly after the time Plan 36
was registered in the late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Machell/Irwin
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 22 of 302
A lex
G
a
r
d
n
e
r
C
i
r
c
l
eMachell AvenueIrwin Av
e
n
u
e
Address: 39 Machell Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 9 Plan 36
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1870
Date Identified/Listed: 1986
Architectural Style/Influence: Georgian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Removal of some original
features and materials.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 36, registered by
Richard Wells and dwellings constructed shortly after the time Plan 36
was registered in the late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Machell/Irwin
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 23 of 302
AlexGardnerCircle
Machell AvenueAddress: 16 Machell Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 19 Plan 36
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1910
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Bay window
Condition Notes: Rear addition and garage
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 36, registered by
Richard Wells and dwellings constructed shortly after the time Plan 36
was registered in the late 19th century
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of
Marshall Forsyth (1855-1933) who bought the property in 1913 as a
vacant lot, for $250. M. Forsyth owned a stationery and music store
on Yonge Street. His younger brother, Wesley Octavius Forsyth, was
a notable Canadian composer.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Machell/Irwin
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 24 of 302
Alex Gardner CircleMachell AvenueAddress: 22 Machell Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 19 Plan 36
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1913
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the industrial base
and/or development of the Machell/Irwin neighbourhood (i.e.
worker’s housing)
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Built and designed by
Michael Shulman and Page Kerry. Michael Shulman is known for
constructing this house in 1912. Shulman is suspected to have built 37
houses throughout Aurora which contributed to the growth of the
town in the early 20th century.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Some association with houses located
to the north which displays similar architectural features (i.e. 22-30
Machell)
Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Machell/Irwin
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 25 of 302
Machell AvenueAlex Gardner Circle
Address: 24 Machell Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 19 Plan 36
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1913
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the industrial base
and/or development of the Machell/Irwin neighbourhood (i.e.
worker’s housing);
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Constructed and designed
by Michael Shulman and Page Kerry. Michael Shulman is known for
constructing this house in 1912. Shulman is suspected to have built 37
houses throughout Aurora which contributed to the growth of the
town in the early 20th century.
See 1921 census - "In 1921 Mr. Kerry sold number 24 to a retired
merchant who owned several investment properties in Aurora. John
Gray and his wife, Jessie, had operated a general store".
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Associated with properties located at
22-30 Machell which are constricted of a similar style at the same
time period
Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Machell/Irwin
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 26 of 302
Machell AvenueAl ex
G
a
rdner Circle
Address: 26 Machell Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 19 Plan 36
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1913
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes: House moved back for excavation. Held up on
steel beams and wood skids.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the industrial base
and/or development of the Machell/Irwin neighbourhood (i.e.
worker’s housing);
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Constructed and designed
by Michael Shulman and Page Kerry. Michael Shulman is known for
constructing this house in 1912. Shulman is suspected to have built 37
houses throughout Aurora which contributed to the growth of the
town in the early 20th century.
The purchasers in 1920 were Alice Flicker, a widow, and her sister,
Mary Jane “May” Hern.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Similar to houses along the street (i.e.
22 - 30 Machell Avenue)Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Machell/Irwin
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 27 of 302
Machell AvenueAlex
G
ardner Circle
Address: 28 Machell Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 18 Plan 36
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1913
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes: Rear addition
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the industrial base
and/or development of the Machell/Irwin neighbourhood (i.e.
worker’s housing);
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Constructed and designed
by Michael Shulman and Page Kerry. Michael Shulman is known for
constructing this house in 1912. Shulman is suspected to have built 37
houses throughout Aurora which contributed to the growth of the
town in the early 20th century.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Machell/Irwin
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 28 of 302
Machell AvenueAlex
G
a
rdner Circle
Address: 30 Machell Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 18 Plan 36
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1913
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the industrial base
and/or development of the Machell/Irwin neighbourhood (i.e.
worker’s housing);
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Constructed and built by
Michael Shulman and Page Kerry. Michael Shulman is known for
constructing this house in 1912. Shulman is suspected to have built 37
houses throughout Aurora which contributed to the growth of the
town in the early 20th century.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Similar to houses located along the
street (i.e. 22-30 Machell Avenue)Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Machell/Irwin
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 29 of 302
Machell AvenueIrwin Av
e
n
u
e
Alex
G
a
r
d
n
e r Circle
Address: 40 Machell Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 17 Plan 36
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1907
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Altered (unknown)
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Unable to conclusively determine whether
or not the house is a vernacular "workers" house or alternatively, an
"L" shaped Victorian.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the industrial base
and/or development of the Machell/Irwin neighbourhood (i.e.
worker’s housing);
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s):
Neighbourhood Group: Machell/Irwin
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1900s
Page 30 of 302
Machell AvenueIrwin Av
e
n
u
e
Address: 48 Machell Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Plan 36
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1880
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Revival
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 36, registered by
Richard Wells and dwellings constructed shortly after the time Plan 36
was registered in the late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Machell/Irwin
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 31 of 302
Machell AvenueIrwin A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 56 Machell Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Plan 36
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1884
Date Identified/Listed: 1986
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes: Renovated with addition, altered original facade.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 36, registered by
Richard Wells and dwellings constructed shortly after the time Plan 36
was registered in the late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Machell/Irwin
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 32 of 302
Machell AvenueIrwin Av
e
n
u
e
Address: 60 Machell Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Plan 36
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1880
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Bay windows on front and south side
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 36, registered by
Richard Wells and dwellings constructed shortly after the time Plan 36
was registered in the late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Machell/Irwin
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 33 of 302
SpruceStreetVictoriaStreetWellingto
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t
Centre S
t
r
e
e
t
Wells StreetWells Street NorthAddress: 46 Wellington Street East
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 20 Plan 107
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1929
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Vernacular (Aurora)
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes: Replaced windows
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 107, which was
registered by Richard Machell in 1853 and forms part of the early
community known as “Machell’s Corners” and buildings constructed
in the 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Wellington Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 34 of 302
Wellingto
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
tSpruceStreetCentre S
t
r
e
e
t
Wells StreetWells Street NorthAddress: 54 Wellington Street East
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 18 Plan 107
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1885
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Period Revival
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Poor
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes: Previous house constructed in 1855, altered in 1883
(unknown if original dwelling was removed) with gambrel roof, elle
wing and bargeboard.
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 107, which was
registered by Richard Machell in 1853 and forms part of the early
community known as “Machell’s Corners” and buildings constructed
in the 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Thomas barber owned the
property between 1855-1866. Thomas Telfer: local farmer and
investor, purchased the property in 1883 for $575.00, who died in
1886. Family sold the property in 1913. Note: Thomas Barber not listed
in Aurora census (1881).
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Wellington Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 35 of 302
Centre S
t
r
e
e
t
Wellingto
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t Larmont StreetWells Street NorthAddress: 78 Wellington Street East
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 12 Plan 107
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1929
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Bungalow
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Wellington Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 36 of 302
Wellingt
o
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t Walton DriveLarmont StreetCentre S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 80-82 Wellington Street East
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 11 Plan 107
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1860
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Georgian
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Poor
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: stucco clad
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the construction of
grand estate homes along Wellington Street in the 19th century;
Associated with Plan 107, which was registered by Richard Machell
in 1853 and forms part of the early community known as “Machell’s
Corners” and buildings constructed in the 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Wellington Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1860s
Page 37 of 302
Wellingt
o
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t
LarmontStreetWalton DriveCentre S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 86 Wellington Street East
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 10 Plan 107
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1865
Date Identified/Listed: 1986
Architectural Style/Influence: Ontario Cottage
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the construction of
grand estate homes along Wellington Street in the 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Wellington Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1860s
Page 38 of 302
LarmontStreetWe llington
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
tWalton DriveCentre S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 94 Wellington Street East
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 8 Plan 107
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1874
Date Identified/Listed: 1986
Architectural Style/Influence: Unknown
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes: Elements of Georgian and Italianate styles
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the construction of
grand estate homes along Wellington Street in the 19th century;
Associated with Plan 107, which was registered by Richard Machell
in 1853 and forms part of the early community known as “Machell’s
Corners” and buildings constructed in the 19th century;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Associated with Clarence
Davis former mayor (and doctor) of Aurora and Warden of York
County; Likely associated with Crawford Rose (Doctor), who formerly
resided at 37 Wellington St. E. in 1957 (see voters list);
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Wellington Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 39 of 302
LarmontStreetWellingto
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
tWalton DriveCentre S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 98 Wellington Street East
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 7 Plan 107
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1874
Date Identified/Listed: 1986
Architectural Style/Influence: Ontario Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the construction of
grand estate homes along Wellington Street in the 19th century;
Associated with Plan 107, which was registered by Richard Machell
in 1853 and forms part of the early community known as “Machell’s
Corners” and buildings constructed in the 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Wellington Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 40 of 302
Wellingt
o
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
tWalton Drive Berczy StreetCentre S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 108 Wellington Street East
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 5 Plan 107
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1880
Date Identified/Listed: 1986
Architectural Style/Influence: Ontario Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 107, which was
registered by Richard Machell in 1853 and forms part of the early
community known as “Machell’s Corners” and buildings constructed
in the 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Wellington Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 41 of 302
Wellingto
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t
Centre S
t
r
e
e
t
Walton DriveBerczy StreetAddress: 116 Wellington Street East
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 3 Plan 107
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1875
Date Identified/Listed: 1986
Architectural Style/Influence: Second Empire
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 107, which was
registered by Richard Machell in 1853 and forms part of the early
community known as “Machell’s Corners” and buildings constructed
in the 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Wellington Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 42 of 302
Wellingto
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t
Centre S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 150 Wellington Street East
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 6 Plan 107
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1930
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Craftsman
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: 1 ½ storey frame; gable rf; twin
pedimented gables; main door in V; bandshe11 porch
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with historical residential
development of wellington street;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Wellington Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1930s
Page 43 of 302
Centre S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 136 Centre Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 1 Plan 107
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1912
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Large rear addition
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with historical residential
development for working people by Michael Shulman
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Michael Shulman is known
for constructing this house in 1912. Shulman is suspected to have
built 37 houses throughout Aurora which contributed to the growth
of the town in the early 20th century.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Centre Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 44 of 302
Centre S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 138 Centre Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 2 Plan 107
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1912
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Rear addition
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with historical residential
development for working people by Michael Shulman
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Michael Shulman is known
for constructing this house in 1912. Shulman is suspected to have
built 37 houses throughout Aurora which contributed to the growth
of the town in the early 20th century.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Centre Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 45 of 302
Centre S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 140 Centre Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 2 Plan 107
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1912
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Roofed verandah built across front
(approx. 2001). New exterior siding and ornate trims (approx. 2001).
Bargeboard added.
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with historical residential
development for working people by Michael Shulman
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Michael Shulman is known
for constructing this house in 1912. Shulman is suspected to have
built 37 houses throughout Aurora which contributed to the growth
of the town in the early 20th century.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Centre Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 46 of 302
Centre CrescentCentre S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 142 Centre Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 3 Plan 107
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1912
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes: Modern material horizontal siding now covers
original stucco and/or insulbrick.
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with historical residential
development for working people by Michael Shulman
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Michael Shulman is known
for constructing this house in 1912. Shulman is suspected to have
built 37 houses throughout Aurora which contributed to the growth
of the town in the early 20th century.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Centre Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 47 of 302
Spruce StreetF
le
uryStreetMaple Stree
t
Address: 77 Spruce Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 4 Plan 67
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1912
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Hip roof, dormer.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Spruce Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 48 of 302
Fleur
y
S
t
r
eetMaple Stree
tSpruce StreetAddress: 79 Spruce Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 3 Plan 67
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1911
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Hip roof, Dormer. Similar style to 87, 85, 83,
and 81 Spruce.
Condition Notes: Exterior addition, front porch enclosed.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Michael Shulman a
prominent house builder in Aurora who built 5 ornamental concrete
brick houses on the street.
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Michael Shulman is known
for constructing this house in 1911. Shulman is suspected to have
built 37 houses throughout Aurora which contributed to the growth
of the town in the early 20th century.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: The 5 houses that Shulman built are of
similar scale and style, made of ornamental concrete brick.
Collectively these houses contribute to the character of the area.
Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Spruce Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 49 of 302
Fle
u
r
y
S
t
r
e
etMaple Stre
e
tSpruce StreetAddress: 81 Spruce Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 2 Plan 67
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1911
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Hip roof, Dormer. Similar style to 87, 85, 83,
79 Spruce.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Michael Shulman a
prominent house builder in Aurora who built 5 ornamental concrete
brick houses on the street.
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Michael Shulman is known
for constructing this house in 1911. Shulman is suspected to have
built 37 houses throughout Aurora which contributed to the growth
of the town in the early 20th century.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: The 5 houses that Shulman built are of
similar scale and style, made of ornamental concrete brick.
Collectively these houses contribute to the character of the area.
Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Spruce Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 50 of 302
Spruce StreetAddress: 83 Spruce Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 1 Plan 67
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1911
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Hip roof, Dormer. Similar style to 79, 81, 85,
87 Spruce.
Condition Notes: Note that this house has retained its integrity to a
greater degree given that it has not been painted.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Michael Shulman a
prominent house builder in Aurora who built 5 ornamental concrete
brick houses on the street.
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Michael Shulman is known
for constructing this house in 1911. Shulman is suspected to have
built 37 houses throughout Aurora which contributed to the growth
of the town in the early 20th century.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: The 5 houses that Shulman built are of
similar scale and style, made of ornamental concrete brick.
Collectively these houses contribute to the character of the area.
Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Spruce Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 51 of 302
Spruce StreetAddress: 85 Spruce Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 1 Plan 67
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1911
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Hip roof, Dormer. Similar style to 79, 81, 83,
87 Spruce.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Michael Shulman a
prominent house builder in Aurora who built 5 ornamental concrete
brick houses on the street.
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Michael Shulman is known
for constructing this house in 1911. Shulman is suspected to have
built 37 houses throughout Aurora which contributed to the growth
of the town in the early 20th century.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: The 5 houses that Shulman built are of
similar scale and style, made of ornamental concrete brick.
Collectively these houses contribute to the character of the area.
Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Spruce Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 52 of 302
Spruce StreetAddress: 87 Spruce Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 1 Plan 67
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1911
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Dormer, hip roof, front porch likely
enclosed in 20th century.
Condition Notes: The original concrete block facade has been
covered with siding.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Michael Shulman who
was a prominent builder, who built 5 ornamental concrete brick
houses on the street.
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: The 5 houses that Shulman built are of
similar scale and style, made of ornamental concrete brick.
Collectively these houses contribute to the character of the area.
Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Spruce Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 53 of 302
Maple
S
t
r
e
e
tSpruce Street
Address: 76 Spruce Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 37 Plan 5
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1915
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Hip roof with front gable.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Representative of Edwardian
style.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: The dwelling was built in
1915, significantly after Doan registered the subdivision in 1865.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Spruce Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 54 of 302
Spruce StreetAddress: 80 Spruce Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 35 Plan 5
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1915
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Dormer, hip roof, covered porch/portico.
Condition Notes: Rear addition, updated windows
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Dwelling built in 1915,
significantly after Doan registered the subdivision in 1865.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Spruce Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 55 of 302
Spruce StreetAddress: 84 Spruce Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 36 Plan 5
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1915
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Dormer, hip roof, covered verandah
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Representative of Foursquare
style
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Dwelling was built in 1915,
significantly after Doan registered the subdivision in 1865.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Spruce Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 56 of 302
Tyler Str
e
e
t Mill StreetGeorge StreetAddress: 58 Tyler Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 1 Plan 30
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed:
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: American Foursquare
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Side entry with porch, stone lintels,
wooden lintels with dentils on second storey. Shed dormer. Four
square.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Recently renovated with
sympathetic alterations. Original attributes and style retained.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the Alexandra Park
subdivision (Plan 30) and residential lots created by A. A. Conover
circa 1912, and the buildings constructed between 1912 and the
mid. 20th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Mrs.
Cesar Calderon (housewife) - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 57 of 302
Wellingto
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t
Mil
l StreetTemperance StreetAddress: 19, 35 and 37 Wellington Street West
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: (various)
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Combination
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Building
Heritage Attributes Notes: Industrial building complex now used
commercially. Various sections of the building, some of the Victorian
era and others 20th century. Victorian sections include decorative
brickwork (dentilling) some original window openings, brick voussoirs.
Rear outbuilding cinder block. c.1859 agricultural foundry?
Condition Notes: Property includes additions. However, building and
property includes remains of original buildings. Many parts of the
19th century portions have been painted. Condition seems fair but
largely not able to be assessed from the public realm.
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: YesSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the industrial/
commercial hub of 19th century Aurora and Wellington Street, East
of Yonge.
Major
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: Yes
Supports the Character of the Area: No
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is a Landmark: Yes
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Downtown Aurora (Yonge Street)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: N/A
Page 58 of 302
Tyler Str
e
e
tMill StreetAddress: 46 Mill Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 1 Plan 30
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1896
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Dwelling includes cross gabled roof,
second storey walkout with iron railings.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Fair example of a Late Victorian
dwelling, unsympathetic single storey addition at front elevation.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: Yes
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the Alexandra Park
subdivision (Plan 30) and residential lots created by A. A. Conover
circa 1912, and the buildings constructed between 1912 and the
mid. 20th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former home of Charles
Murphy (chemist) and Mrs. Murphy - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1890s
Page 59 of 302
Yonge StreetTemperance StreetTyler Str
e
e
t
Address: 7 Tyler Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 7 Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1888
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: L shaped floor plan, open gabled roof,
side hall entry. Protruding bay with decorative brick work and
voussoir. Architecture similar to that of 11 Tyler.
Condition Notes: Brick painted, new windows installed, foundation
parged and painted.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Fair example of a Victorian
dwelling with some unsympathetic alterations (including front
addition).
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the Alexandra Park
subdivision and residential lots created by A. A. Conover circa 1912,
and the buildings constructed between 1912 and the mid. 20th
century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Likely constructed c. 1888
by Philip L. Querrie (investment property). Former residence of Allan
Profit (hospital attendant) and Mrs. Hilda Profit - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Similar to the adjacent building at 11
Tyler Street (constructed as a pair at the same time).Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Downtown Aurora (Yonge Street)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 60 of 302
Yonge StreetTemperance StreetTyler Str
e
e
t
Address: 11 Tyler Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 7 Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1888
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: L shaped floor plan, protruding window
section on side bays with decorative brickwork. Brick voussoirs. Cross-
gable roof. Front addition . Rear addition. Architecture similar to that
of 7 Tyler.
Condition Notes: Some deterioration of brick.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Fair example of a Victorian
building with some unsympathetic alterations (including addition at
front elevation).
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the Alexandra Park
subdivision and residential lots created by A. A. Conover circa 1912,
and the buildings constructed between 1912 and the mid. 20th
century. Likely constructed c. 1888 for Philip L. Querrie (considerable
increase in price between previous year suggests a building may
have been constructed at this time.) Former residence of Alan White
(kitchen helper) and Mrs. Beverley White -1957
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Similar to the building at 7 Tyler Street.Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1890s
Page 61 of 302
Yonge StreetTemperance StreetTyler Str
e
e
t
Address: 15 Tyler Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1923
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Vernacular (Aurora)
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Fair example of a 1920s cottage/
bungalow.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Note: Aurora Banner article
February 1923: John Bowser constructing a dwelling on Tyler Street at
Temperance, formerly "Stork" (?) property. Former residence of
William Mugford (retired) and Mrs. Elizabeth Mugford (shoe operator)
- 1957.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1930s
Page 62 of 302
Tyler Str
e
e
tMill StreetTemperance StreetAddress: 35 Tyler Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description:
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: pre- 1988
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Revival
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: High pitched centred gable; dual entry as
duplex, brick voussoirs. Row of mature coniferous trees centred on
property.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Fair example of a Gothic revival
building. Unknown if building was originally constructed as a semi-
detached dwelling.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the Alexandra Park
subdivision and residential lots created by A. A. Conover circa 1912,
and the buildings constructed between 1912 and the mid. 20th
century;
Former residence of William Potvin (reporter) and Mrs. Mary Potvin -
1957
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of William
Potvin (reporter) and Mary Potvin - 35 Tyler Street
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 63 of 302
Mill StreetTyler Str
e
e
t
Temperance StreetAddress: 37 Tyler Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description:
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: pre. 1888
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Revival
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: High pitched centred gable, brick
voussoirs.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Unknown if the building was
originally constructed as a semi-detached. Fair example of a Gothic
revival cottage.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the Alexandra Park
subdivision and residential lots created by A. A. Conover circa 1912,
and the buildings constructed between 1912 and the mid. 20th
century;
Former residence of John Branbury (butcher) and Isabel Branbury -
1957
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: * Notation in the Aurora
Banner November 1888 noting the renovation of a semi-detached
brick residence on Tyler Street. Building was therefore constructed
prior to 1888.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 64 of 302
Tyler Str
e
e
t
George StreetAddress: 59 Tyler Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 27 Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1874
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Regency
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Building
Heritage Attributes Notes: Intersecting hipped roof, centred entry.
Brick voussoirs.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Well preserved example of a
Regency era cottage.
Major
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the Alexandra Park
subdivision (Plan 30) and residential lots created by A. A. Conover
circa 1912, and the buildings constructed between 1912 and the
mid. 20th century;
Also assocaited with early Plan 9 "Lynn's Plan", pre-confederation.
Major
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Property likely included a
frame dwelling as early as 1850s. Land was owned by members of
the Machell family, and used by Edwin Machell. After the death of
Edwin Machell, the land was owned by Walter Machell (c. 1879)
who tore down the wood frame structure and constructed the
existing building using bricks from his brickyard. Site of a brickworks
established by Walter Machell c. 1874. Indirectly associated with
Richard Machell.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Located adjacent to the creek and
riverbed which provided clay for brick making.Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 65 of 302
Tyler Str
e
e
t
George StreetAddress: 63 Tyler Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 27 Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Cross hipped medium pitched gabled
roof. Bay window. Brick voussoirs. Large mature tree in front yard, row
of coniferous to the rear.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Fair example of a Victorian
dwelling. Existing front addition is unsympathetic.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the Alexandra Park
subdivision (Plan 30) and residential lots created by A. A. Conover
circa 1912, and the buildings constructed between 1912 and the
mid. 20th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Likely constructed between
1881 and 1887 under the ownership of James Brothers (noted as a
carpenter in the 1891 Aurora census). Sold in 1887 to Thomas Crake
(1/4 acre lot). Thomas Crake is noted as a farmer in the 1871 census
of Whitchurch twp.
Former residence of Raymond Mason (railroad worker) - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: Yes
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 66 of 302
George StreetTyler Str
e
e
t
Address: 79 Tyler Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 28 Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed:
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Bungalow
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Centred entryway. Medium pitched open
gabled roof. Open gabled front porch. Large mature trees in front
yard and row along George Street frontage. Cottage c. 1930s
Condition Notes: Exterior clad in stucco.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Bungalow with craftsman
influences. Some unsympathetic alterations. Unknown if existing front
porch is original.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the Alexandra Park
subdivision (Plan 30) and residential lots created by A. A. Conover
circa 1912, and the buildings constructed between 1912 and the
mid. 20th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: May be (indirectly)
associated with John "Jack" Bowser who superintended the
construction of the Empire State Building in the 1930s. Note: Bowser
not noted as a resident of Aurora in the 1935, 1945 or 1953 voters
lists. *did not reside on the property
Former residence of Harold Rogers (traveller) and Mrs Winnifred
Rogers - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1930s
Page 67 of 302
Har
r
ima
n
Road
T yler
S
t
r
eetAddress: 121 Tyler Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 25 Plan 30
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1914
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling and Outbuilding
Heritage Attributes Notes: Open gable roof, front porch, L-shaped
plan. Rear additions. Clad in siding.
Low pitched roof outbuilding to the rear of the house.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Workers Dwelling, 1925 addition
to the west side creating "L" shaped house.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Former home of Charles Murphy
(chemist) and Mrs. Murphy - 1957
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Constructed for William
Shelberg c. 1914
Named "Braeside" by John Stuart (plumber) and Agnes Stuart
John Stuart served on Town Coucnil for nine years (1930s and 1940s)
Also known as "Stuart House".
Sold to Charles and Ethel Billing in 1944. Former residence of James
Beattie (watchman) and Mrs Minnie Beattie - 1957 (see voters list).
James Beattie is also noted as a baker at Scanlon's bakery.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Likely included surrounding properties
which have been subdivided since the early 20th century. In-filled
with residential lots.
Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 68 of 302
Mill StreetTemperance StreetTyler Str
e
e
t
Address: 28 Tyler Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 20 Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1923
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Vernacular (Aurora)
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Open gabled roof, front porch, side hall
entry, brick voussoir, rear lean to addition. Detached garage/shed.
Mature tree, adjacent to stream.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare:Early (pre-1867): NoUnique:Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Worker's house
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Historical theme of local, 19th and
early 21st century industry which includes the worker neighbourhood
and industrial buildings of Tyler Street.
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Worker's cottage supporting
the labour for surrounding industries.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: Yes
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Maintains and supports the historic
worker's neighbourhood.Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 69 of 302
Tyler Str
e
e
t Temperance StreetMill StreetAddress: 38 Tyler Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed:
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Revival
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Centred high pitched gable, centred
entryway with front porch. Lancet window opening replaced. Brick
voussoirs and rear wing.
Condition Notes: Most window openings have been altered
including signature lancet window.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Representative of Gothic Revival
architectural style.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Historical theme of local, 19th and
early 21st century industry which includes the worker neighbourhood
and industrial buildings of Tyler Street.
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Associated with the theme
of industrial neighbourhoods.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: Yes
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: The property maintains and supports
the character of the area.Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 70 of 302
Tyler Str
e
e
tMill StreetAddress: 42 Tyler Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 22 Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed:
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling and Outbuilding
Heritage Attributes Notes: Dichromatic brick, brick quoins and
voussoirs. Open gabled roof with returning /extended eaves. Side
entry with porch. Detached garage/shed.
Condition Notes: Some alterations to brick work and signs masonry
cracking.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Representative of a late
Victorian.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Historical theme of local, 19th and
early 21st century industry which includes the worker neighbourhood
and industrial buildings of Tyler Street.
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: Yes
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Supports and maintains the character
of the area.Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 71 of 302
Mill StreetTyler Str
e
e
t
Address: 46 Tyler Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 1 Plan 30
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1887
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Revival
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: High pitched gables. Many alterations
completed challenging to differentiate old and new in some areas.
Brick voussoirs and intersecting gable roof.
Condition Notes: Large addition on house.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: Yes
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Representative of Gothic Revival
architectural style.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Former home of Charles Murphy
(chemist) and Mrs. Murphy - 1957
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 72 of 302
George StreetTyler Str
e
e
t
Address: 62 Tyler Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 1 Plan 30
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1904
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Includes stone quoin and shed dormer.
Condition Notes: Repointed brick.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Representative of the Edwardian
architectural style.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the Alexandra Park
subdivision (Plan 30) and residential lots created by A. A. Conover
circa 1912, and the buildings constructed between 1912 and the
mid. 20th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1900s
Page 73 of 302
George StreetTyler Str
e
e
t
Address: 66 Tyler Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 2 Plan 30
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1875
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Vernacular (Aurora)
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Medium pitched gable roof, Side hall
entry, large open porch/verandah with decorative woodwork.
Wood finial on main gable.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the Alexandra Park
subdivision (Plan 30) and residential lots created by A. A. Conover
circa 1912, and the buildings constructed between 1912 and the
mid. 20th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: Yes
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range:
Page 74 of 302
George StreetTyler Str
e
e
t
Address: 70 Tyler Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 3 Plan 30
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1915-1925
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Side hall entry, front porch supported by
wood columns (balustrades and Doric columns). Small window
opening on main storey with detailing. Brick voussoirs. Four square.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the Alexandra Park
subdivision (Plan 30) and residential lots created by A. A. Conover
circa 1912, and the buildings constructed between 1912 and the
mid. 20th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: Early 20th Century
Page 75 of 302
George StreetTyler Str
e
e
t
Address: 74 Tyler Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 4 Plan 30
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1888
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Side hall entry with overhang. Bay window
and open gable. Brick voussoirs.
Condition Notes: Green asphalt roof and metal trim.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Representative of late Victorian
dwelling.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the Alexandra Park
subdivision (Plan 30) and residential lots created by A. A. Conover
circa 1912, and the buildings constructed between 1912 and the
mid. 20th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: Yes
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 76 of 302
George StreetTyler Str
e
e
t
Address: 78 Tyler Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 5 Plan 30
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1905
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Altered (unknown)
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Hipped roof. 1970 aerial may indicate that
a large portion of the dwelling was contstructed as an addition.
Unknown if brick or board and batten portion of the dwelling consists
of a later addition.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Architectural style and original
features difficult to distinguish. Integrity compromised.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the Alexandra Park
subdivision (Plan 30) and residential lots created by A. A. Conover
circa 1912, and the buildings constructed between 1912 and the
mid. 20th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1900s
Page 77 of 302
George StreetTyler Str
e
e
t
Address: 80 Tyler Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 14 Plan 30
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1888
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Front porch with classical columns and
woodwork, second storey sunroom, double, high-pitched gables on
side elevation. Decorative wood window surrounds.
Condition Notes: Original window frames (appears), original wood
work in good condition.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the Alexandra Park
subdivision (Plan 30) and residential lots created by A. A. Conover
circa 1912, and the buildings constructed between 1912 and the
mid. 20th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Likely constructed for John
Ouch c. 1888, sold to Albert Ough 1889. Former residence of George
Beach (millwright) and Miss George Beach - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: Yes
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 78 of 302
HarrimanRoadGeorge StreetTyler Str
e
e
t
Address: 96 Tyler Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 19 Plan 30
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1931
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Other
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Open gable with front porch.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the Alexandra Park
subdivision (Plan 30) and residential lots created by A. A. Conover
circa 1912, and the buildings constructed between 1912 and the
mid. 20th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Constructed by J.A. Knowles
(Knowles and Pattenden) c. 1931. Constructed for Thomas Sisman -
of the Sisman Shoe Company. Home of Roscoe Linton - Thomas
Sisman's Grandson. Ross Linton - Councillor 1939
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1930s
Page 79 of 302
Temperance StreetReuben
S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 23 Reuben Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 34 Plan 39
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1912
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Wrap around front porch, stone quoins,
series of gabled rooflines. Semicircular window openings. Stone lintels
and sills.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Some alterations which have
changed the appearance of the building - including large
verandah and addition of new siding.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: Yes
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 39, Surveyed by
P.S. Gibson (Ontario Land Surveyor) for R. J. Kennedy in 1876 (Part of
North half of Lot 79, Concession1, King Twp) and dwellings
constructed between 1879 and the early 20th century.;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Eva
Radford and George Radford (banker) - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 80 of 302
Temperance StreetReuben
S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 27 Reuben Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 31 Plan 39
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Open gable roof, front porch with wood
posts, rear addition. Brick voussoirs.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Likely a Workers House with
added verandah.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 39, Surveyed by
P.S. Gibson (Ontario Land Surveyor) for R. J. Kennedy in 1876 (Part of
North half of Lot 79, Concession1, King Twp) and dwellings
constructed between 1879 and the early 20th century.;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Charles
Boynton (retired) and Miss Leila Boynton )secretary) - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: No
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: Early 20th Century
Page 81 of 302
Temperance StreetReuben
S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 29 Reuben Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 30 Plan 39
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1912
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Craftsman
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Centred gable dormer, dual stone
chimneys on either side of roof, sloping roof, cobble stone exterior/
veneer.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Fair example of a cobblestone
Craftsman dwelling. Some unsympathetic alterations, including
enclosed porch and attached garage. Unknown if front gable is
original (note: comparison with 1970s aerial shows that front gable
may have been enlarged)
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 39, Surveyed by
P.S. Gibson (Ontario Land Surveyor) for R. J. Kennedy in 1876 (Part of
North half of Lot 79, Concession1, King Twp) and dwellings
constructed between 1879 and the early 20th century.;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of John
Willis (druggist) and Anne Willis
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 82 of 302
Temperance StreetReuben
S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 31 Reuben Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 27 Plan 39
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1925
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Craftsman
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling and Outbuilding
Heritage Attributes Notes: Slopes roof with large brick chimney. Large
front porch with brick and wood columns. Original window and door
openings appear to be original. Brick voussoirs. Central hipped/shed
dormer. Contemporary detached garage.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 39, Surveyed by
P.S. Gibson (Ontario Land Surveyor) for R. J. Kennedy in 1876 (Part of
North half of Lot 79, Concession1, King Twp) and dwellings
constructed between 1879 and the early 20th century.;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Alfred
S. Jubb (aircraft inspector) and Theresa Jubb - 1957 and 1963 voters
lists. A. E. Jubb - RCAF
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 83 of 302
Yonge StreetTemperance StreetReuben
S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 18-20 Reuben Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 7 Plan 39
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Poor
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Bay windows, brick voussoirs. Open gable
roof.
Condition Notes: Water drainage issues visible.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Likely Victorian - additions over
time (compare FIP with 1970 aerial) some removal of original
attributes. Wood frame, brick veneer.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 39, Surveyed by
P.S. Gibson (Ontario Land Surveyor) for R. J. Kennedy in 1876 (Part of
North half of Lot 79, Concession1, King Twp) and dwellings
constructed between 1879 and the early 20th century.;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of B.E.
MacDonnell (widow) - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group:
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: Late 19th Century
Page 84 of 302
Temperance StreetReuben
S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 28 Reuben Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 12 Plan 39
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.18890
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: L shaped plan with open gabled roof and
protruding window bay with decorative brick.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 39, Surveyed by
P.S. Gibson (Ontario Land Surveyor) for R. J. Kennedy in 1876 (Part of
North half of Lot 79, Concession1, King Twp) and dwellings
constructed between 1879 and the early 20th century.;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: George T. Browning (local
builder) purchased part of lots 12, 13, and 14 in 1888. Price of the lot
suggests lot was vacant. Property tenanted by Henry Ross, house
painter in the 1890s. Property purchased from Browning by Mary
Cain in 1891. M. Cain resided on the property until 1926, Lucinda
Cain resided on the property until 1942. Emily Shanks (widow,
seamstress) purchased the property in 1946.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group:
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1890s
Page 85 of 302
Temperance Street
Reuben
S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 30 Reuben Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 15 Plan 39
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Georgian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Original openings including windows and
doors. Front porch with wood posts and railings. Open gabled roof
with return eaves.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Georgian Cottage,
sympathetically altered. Retained overall scale/massing, 3-bay
facade and side-gable roofline.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 39, Surveyed by
P.S. Gibson (Ontario Land Surveyor) for R. J. Kennedy in 1876 (Part of
North half of Lot 79, Concession1, King Twp) and dwellings
constructed between 1879 and the early 20th century.;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Donald
Hope (construction), Norman Hope (farmer) and Hazel Hope - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1860s
Page 86 of 302
Yonge StreetKenned
y
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t
Kennedy
Str eet
E
a
s
t
Temperance StreetAddress: 7 Kennedy Street West
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 5 Plan 131
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1915
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Intersecting gable roofs, open gable on
front elevation. Front porch with wooden columns. Brick voussoirs
and stone sills. Second storey sunroom addition.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Distinctive grouping of
Edwardian buildings along the south side of Kennedy Street
West.Constructed by Benjamin Stephenson. Property sold to Janet
Rogers (widow) 1915. Property sold to Thomas Cairns (1926). Sold to
Frederick C. Davis in 1943 (for Joseph Thomas Elwood Davis).
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: Yes
Supports the Character of the Area: No
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 87 of 302
YongeStreetKennedy
Street
E
a
s
t
Kenned
y
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t
Temperance StreetAddress: 11 Kennedy Street West
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 4 Plan 131
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1914
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling and Outbuilding
Heritage Attributes Notes: Intersecting rooflines, open gable on front
elevation, front porch with wooden columns. Stone headers and sills.
Detached garage.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme:
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of George
R. Legge (retired), and Mrs May Legge (1957). The Legge family
owned the property from 1932 - 1972.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: Yes
Supports the Character of the Area: No
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Distinctive grouping of Edwardian
buildings along the south side of Kennedy Street West.Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 88 of 302
YongeStreetTemperance StreetKenned
y
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t
Address: 15 Kennedy Street West
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 3 Plan 131
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1913
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Open gabled roof, verandah, stone
headers and sills.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Elvie
Bishop retired teacher (1957)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: Yes
Supports the Character of the Area: No
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Distinctive grouping of Edwardian
buildings along the south side of Kennedy Street West.Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 89 of 302
Temperance StreetKenned
y
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t
Yonge Street
Address: 19 Kennedy Street West
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 2 Plan 131
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1913
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Pyramid hip roof with hipped dormers,
front porch with wood columns and railings. Stone sills and headers/
lintel.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Mrs
Gertrude Wilson (widow)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: Yes
Supports the Character of the Area: No
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Distinctive grouping of Edwardian
buildings along the south side of Kennedy Street West.Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 90 of 302
Temperance StreetYongeStreetKenned
y
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t
Address: 21 Kennedy Street West
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 1 Plan 131
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1913
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Hipped roof. Brick voussoirs.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of
Gertrude Bull (widow) 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: Yes
Supports the Character of the Area: No
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Distinctive grouping of Edwardian
buildings along the south side of Kennedy Street West.Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 91 of 302
Temperance StreetKenned
y
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t
Address: 29 Kennedy Street West
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 45 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1915
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling and Outbuilding
Heritage Attributes Notes: Intersecting gabled roof, front porch with
wood posts. Stone sills and lintels, fanlight on front open gable.
Octagonal window opening. "The Fry Smith House".
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Charles Fry (King City
insurance agent) purchased 2.4 hectares of land, sub-divided and
constructed residences. 1927 dwelling rented to tenants, 1928 sold to
Cyrus Dunham. Maud Dunham and William McCarl sold the property
in 1950. Former residence of Donald Smith (baker - Scanlon) and
Florence Smith (1957)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 92 of 302
RansomStreetAddress: 41 Kennedy Street West
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 38 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1925
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Craftsman
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Intersecting roof lines, stone foundation,
porch include stone entry stairway. Appears to be original window
openings. House is by bank of Creek and landscaping is designed to
engage the house into the overall natural scene.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: Yes Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: House as part of Aurora's
historical Society's annual house tour in 1990, 1992 and featured in
Century Home magazine in 1993.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Physically and visually linked to the
pond that was created by original owner Bonisteel as part of the
overall property.
Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 93 of 302
Kenned
y
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t
George S
t
reetAddress: 81 Kennedy Street West
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 36 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed:
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Combination
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Gabled dormers. Stone exterior.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare:Early (pre-1867):Unique:Representative:High Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit:
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement:
Design/Physical Value Description:
None
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event:Significant Person:
Significant Activity:Significant Organization/Institution:
Significant Theme Description:
None
Significant Theme:
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area:
None
Maintains the Character of the Area:
Supports the Character of the Area:
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings:
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings:
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings:
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings:
Is a Landmark:
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group:
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 20th Century
Page 94 of 302
Kenned
y
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t
Address: 133 Kennedy Street West
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 33 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed:
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Ontario Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling and Outbuilding
Heritage Attributes Notes: Low pitched open gable roof with front
porch. Rear additions. Many mature trees on site. Gabled dormers.
Cottage. Wood exterior cladding.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: Yes
Supports the Character of the Area: No
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: Early 20th Century
Page 95 of 302
Temperance StreetKenned
y
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t
Kenned
y
S
t
r
e
e
t
EastYonge StreetAddress: 8 Kennedy Street West
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 39 Plan 39
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1930
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Bungalow
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Side hall entry with decorative Classical
door surround. Open gable roof.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Building does not display features
indicative of a particular architectural style, likely due to removal of
attributes. May have been influenced by the Craftsman era.
None
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Robert
Patchell (construction) and Joan Patchell
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1930s
Page 96 of 302
Temperance StreetKennedy
Street
East
Kenned
y
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t YongeStreetAddress: 12 Kennedy Street West
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 38 Plan 39
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1935
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Bungalow
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Angel brick foundation, stone headers
and sills, bay window and turret like bay window.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Removal of original features
- alteration to roof, re-clad exposed foundation, new railing (alters
original appearance). Former residence of Walter Dunning
(carpenter) and Mrs Viola Dunning (1957).
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1930s
Page 97 of 302
Reu ben
Street
Temperance StreetKenned
y
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t
Address: 26 Kennedy Street West
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 32 Plan 39
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1881
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Altered (unknown)
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: "John F. Kendall" Blacksmith, 1881.
Centered gable dormer (likely a later addition). Side and front
elevation additions (do not contribute to the dwelling).
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Likely a Georgian or Revival
cottage which has been unsympathetically altered. Not a
representative example of an early cottage.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 39, Surveyed by
P.S. Gibson (Ontario Land Surveyor) for R. J. Kennedy in 1876 (Part of
North half of Lot 79, Concession1, King Twp) and dwellings
constructed between 1879 and the early 20th century.;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Purchased in 1881 by John
F. Kendall, sold in 1900 to James Cannon. Purchased by James
Daniels in 1905.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 98 of 302
ReubenStreetTemperance StreetKenned
y
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t
Address: 28 Kennedy Street West
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 29 Plan 39
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Altered (unknown)
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Gabled roof with front porch and wood
posts and railings. Original window and door openings and open
gabled side addition. Saltbox roofline. Likely a Georgian or Revival
cottage.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Features have been altered -
architectural style is difficult to confirm. Addition with gable (Gothic
style) window does not communicate a Georgian cottage style.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 39, Surveyed by
P.S. Gibson (Ontario Land Surveyor) for R. J. Kennedy in 1876 (Part of
North half of Lot 79, Concession1, King Twp) and dwellings
constructed between 1879 and the early 20th century.;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of John
Closs (shoe cutter) and Olive Closs (1957)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 99 of 302
Kenned
y
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t Temperance StreetAddress: 34 Kennedy Street West
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 25 Plan 39
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Altered (unknown)
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling and Outbuilding
Heritage Attributes Notes: Ontario cottage with front porch. Added
stone veneer to original building and side additions. Detached
garage.
Condition Notes: Several renovations completed.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Original materials and features
removed. Only side-gable roofline and 1.5 storey massing remain.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 39, Surveyed by
P.S. Gibson (Ontario Land Surveyor) for R. J. Kennedy in 1876 (Part of
North half of Lot 79, Concession1, King Twp) and dwellings
constructed between 1879 and the early 20th century.;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Victor
Jones (tanner) and Mrs. Evelyn Jones (See 1935 and 1957 voters lists)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 100 of 302
Kenned
y
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
tGeorge StreetAddress: 88 Kennedy Street West
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 3 Plan 38
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1913
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Contemporary
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Altered in approximately 2010. Majority of
original materials and attributes removed. Formerly a representative
example of an Edwardian dwelling with Queen Anne Revival
influences (estate home).
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Extent of alterations have
compromised heritage integrity (2010 alterations), extension of roof,
removal and alteration of window openings, alteration of porch, etc.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Moderate
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Associated with Richard
Watson Woodsworth, leading financiers in the Methodist Church,
who resided in the building until he died in 1917. House was later
rented, sold to Mancel Wilmot in 1919 (architect by occupation, also
grew apples). Purchased by C. and W. Greaves in 1922, constructed
a house for a gardener. 1931 sold to R. and F. Killingsworth. 1946
prchased by J. Crysdale (broker).
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
None
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 101 of 302
Yonge Street
Church
S
t
r
e
e
t
Temperance Street
Address: 15120 Yonge Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 3 Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1880
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Altered (unknown)
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Commercial Building
Heritage Attributes Notes: The Atkinson House
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Note that there are references to
the construction of the building c.1850. Considerable alterations to
building - roof raised, removal of original window and door
openings, or alteration of materials and features.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with theme of commercial
development in the downtown Commercial core of Aurora and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Major
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: May have originally been
constructed for industrial/commercial use and converted back and
forth through the years. W. Atkinson served as member of Council
1875. FIP 1913 indicates property included a Blacksmith Shop
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 102 of 302
Temperance StreetYonge StreetAddress: 15114 Yonge Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 2 Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1830
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Unknown
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Building
Heritage Attributes Notes: Quaker Meeting House. Covered in tarps -
existing features not presently visible (under renovation).
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Major
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: YesSignificant Organization/Institution: Yes
Significant Theme Description:
Major
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Formerly part of the Quaker
Meeting House, moved to existing site from Pine Orchard Cemetery
in December 1945. Meeting House was constructed c. 1830
according to the Pine Orchard history (1800-1936). It was being
"finished off" from 1844-1847. Formerly Ken-Steph Lighting
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: No
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Building was re-located to the existing
site during the 1940s.Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1830s
Page 103 of 302
Reuben
S
t
r
e
e
t
Yonge StreetTemperance StreetAddress: 15054 Yonge Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 57 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1866
Date Identified/Listed: 1977
Architectural Style/Influence: Combination
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: The Lundy House (H.D. Lundy, Mayor 1889,
1890)
Pedimented centred porch, low pitched open gabled roof with
decorative bargeboard and box ends. Bay window.
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Integrity has been compromised -
architectural design difficult to confirm. 1988 LACAC notes suggests
"Ontario House"
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Major
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Associated with H.D. Lundy,
Mayor (1889, 1890)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Downtown Aurora (Yonge Street)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1860s
Page 104 of 302
Yonge StreetReuben
S
t
r
e
e
t
Temperance StreetAddress: 15048 Yonge Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 58 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1872
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Ontario Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Former dwelling used for commercial
purposes. Cottage with open gabled roof with boxed ends. Later
front addition/ sunroom made to the front elevation.
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Yonge Street Neighbourhood
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Associated with McGaffin
Family.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: No
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: One of the early residences along
Yonge Street in Aurora.Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Downtown Aurora (Yonge Street)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 105 of 302
Reuben
S
t
r
e
e
t
Yonge StreetTemperance StreetKenned
y
Street
W
e
s
t
Kennedy
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t
Address: 15040 Yonge Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 59 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1860
Date Identified/Listed: 1977
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Cottage
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Joseph Fleury House
Intersecting gable roof. Centred gable on front elevation. Front
porch and rear additions. Bay window.
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Building is no longer a
representative example of a Gothic Cottage. Majority of original
materials have been removed.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: • Associated with theme of
commercial development in the downtown Commercial core of
Aurora and buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Major
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Unknown if a Blacksmith
shop was present on-site.
J. Fleury noted as a member of Council 1866, 1867, 1868, 1869.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Downtown Aurora (Yonge Street)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1860s
Page 106 of 302
Kenned
y
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t
Yonge StreetTemperance StreetKennedy
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t
Address: 15018 Yonge Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 6 Plan 131
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1915
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Queen Anne
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Former dwelling used as commercial
building. Semicircular Bay. Brick voussoirs.
Condition Notes: Cobbleatone wall in poor condition with
unsympathetic repairs.
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Moderate
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Noted as being constructed
by Benjamin Stephenson (Edwardian), who may have resided next
door (to the south at 15010 Yonge).
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Downtown Aurora (Yonge Street)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 107 of 302
Kennedy
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t
YongeStreetTemperance StreetKennedy
Str eet
E
a
s
tAddress: 15010 Yonge Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 7 Plan 131
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1915
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Pedimented porch with wood column
supports on brick pillars. Open gabled roof. Brick voussoirs.
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Constructed for Benjamin
Stephenson c. 1915
Sold to Frederick J. Black (gentleman) 1922
Sold to Mr. E. McCready 1944 (noted as a wrestler by occupation)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Downtown Aurora (Yonge Street)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 108 of 302
Temperance StreetKennedy
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t
Yonge StreetAddress: 15004 Yonge Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 64 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1860
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Altered (unknown)
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Verandah with wooden posts. Low
pitched/ pediment like gable on front facade. Rear addition/wing.
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Removal of original attributes has
diminished a level of its integrity. LACAC details suggest building was
Classical Revival (Neo-Classical?)
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Constructed by Benjamin
Pearson
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Downtown Aurora (Yonge Street)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1860s
Page 109 of 302
Temperance StreetYonge StreetAddress: 15000 Yonge Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 65 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Open gables along roofline, brick
voussoirs. Large later addition to front of house concealing original
attributes (glass sunroom addition).
Condition Notes: Not sure of the extent the building fabric has been
removed for new addition.
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
None
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Downtown Aurora (Yonge Street)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1890s
Page 110 of 302
Yonge StreetRansom
StreetTemperance Street
Address: 14988 Yonge Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 66 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1918
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Craftsman
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Open gabled dormer with box end eaves.
Dual brick chimneys. Original stone porch, however, since enclosed.
Stone foundation. Brick voussoirs and stone sills. Deep medium
pitched roof.
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
None
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Downtown Aurora (Yonge Street)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 111 of 302
Address: Yonge Street W/s
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 77 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed:
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: N/A
Integrity: N/A
Current Owner:
Condition: N/A
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Landscape
Heritage Attributes Notes: Several mature trees, Eagle Bridge over
Creek. Open landscaped space and trail.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare:Early (pre-1867):Unique:Representative:High Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit:
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement:
Design/Physical Value Description:
None
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event:Significant Person:
Significant Activity:Significant Organization/Institution:
Significant Theme Description:
None
Significant Theme:
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area:
None
Maintains the Character of the Area:
Supports the Character of the Area:
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings:
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings:
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings:
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings:
Is a Landmark:
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group:
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: N/A
Page 112 of 302
Church
Street
Yonge StreetTemperance StreetAddress: 83 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 4 Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1865
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Vernacular (Aurora)
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Ireland Moore House. Saltbox roof.
Centered entry way/ portico. Stucco exterior
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Moderate
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Associated with the Ireland
family who were carpenters and builders (and undertakers) by
trade: they were responsible for erecting the 1874 drill shed or
armoury in the Town Park.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1860s
Page 113 of 302
Yonge StreetChurch
Street
Temperance StreetAddress: 87 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 3 Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1900
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Altered (unknown)
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Open gabled roof. L shaped floor plan.
Side addition which is noted on the 1904 rev. 1913 FIP. 2006/2007
building raised and set on new foundation, enlarged on the north
side, new cladding.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Likely constructed c. 1881
when Philip Querrie deeded the land to his brother John Querrie.
Indirectly associated with P. Querrie. J. C. Querrie was a member of
Council in 1888,1889,1895, 1896. Purchased by William Brown in 1885,
remained in the family until 1910. Several other owners noted in
attached document.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1900s
Page 114 of 302
Temperance StreetYonge StreetAddress: 89 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 3 Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Altered (unknown)
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Retains 3-bay facade.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Building retains overall 1.5 storey
scale and massing and 3-bay facade. Unknown if stucco exterior is
original.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Lot owned by M. Lepper in
1857 (2 acres). Lepper likely never resided on the lot. Lepper is noted
as a Mayor of Aurora for a number of years. 14 acre lot owned by
George Atkinson from 1860 - 1863. Sold to William Mortson 1863. Sold
to Northup J. Peck 1865.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1860s
Page 115 of 302
Temperance StreetYonge StreetAddress: 91 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 2 Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Revival
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling and Outbuilding
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Building has been altered.
Original front elevation (facing south) has been altered, existing west
elevation faces Temperance Street. Some unsympathetic
alterations. Building's Gothic Cottage features are not retained and/
or visible from the street.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of
Rowland Moddle (teacher) and Winnifred Moddle – 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: Mid. 19th Century
Page 116 of 302
Yonge StreetTemperance StreetAddress: 95 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 1 Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1861
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Ontario Cottage
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: "John E; McNally House". Original window
openings (majority), brick voussoirs. Several additions (sympathetic).
Ontario cottage. Original front elevation is now in the rear yard
(originally fronted Yonge Street to the east).
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Temperance Street neighbourhood.
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Associated with John
McNally who was a member of the school board, town treasurer
and played a role in the establishment of the first lending library in
Aurora. Also associated with Jean Baker Pearce, a journalist and
publisher of the Aurora Banner.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: The house originally faced Yonge
Street. The house is one of the earliest houses on the street.Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1860s
Page 117 of 302
Yonge StreetTemperanceStreetAddress: 99 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 47 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Four Square house with low pitched gable.
Enclosed front porch.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Some changes to original window
openings (i.e. second storey rectangular window opening)
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Rene
(storeman) and Shiela Bonnebaigt -1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 118 of 302
Yonge StreetTemperance StreetAddress: 101 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 49 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1911
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Open gable roof. Front porch with side hall
entry. Stone detailing including quoins, lintels and sills and arched
keystone surround in window in main elevation. Side addition/
mudroom.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Well preserved example of a
Workers House building.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Moderate
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Constructed c. 1910 or 1911
for George Browning. Subsequently sold to Fred Browning in
1911.Sold to Mrs. Ellanor Milgate in 1911. Former residence of
Reverend Cornelius Dyke and family c. 1918. Mrs. Dyke may have
resided in the house until 1976. Discrepancy as 1957 voters list shows
residents of 101 Temperance as Mrs F. Dunham (may indicate
tenancy). *Note: Reverend Dyke may not have an association with
any local church. Requires confirmation.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 119 of 302
Yonge StreetReuben
StreetTemperanceStreetAddress: 103 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 50 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Poor
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: L shaped floor plan with open gabled
roof. Protruding window bay. Front addition.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Unsympathetic alterations
including existing cladding (over brick) and enclosed front porch.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: YesSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Moderate
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Edward
Payne (retired) and Christina Payne - 1957
Indicated as the location of a Polling station in the 1950s (see
attached).
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 120 of 302
Yonge StreetReuben
S
t
r
e
e
tTemperance Street
Address: 107 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 8 Plan 39
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1935
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Bungalow
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Porch has been enclosed. Existing
bargeboard has been added and does not complement the style
of the building. Likely a Craftsman building constructed in the 1930s
(does not appear on 1927 FIP).
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 39, Surveyed by
P.S. Gibson (Ontario Land Surveyor) for R. J. Kennedy in 1876 (Part of
North half of Lot 79, Concession1, King Twp) and dwellings
constructed between 1879 and the early 20th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Formerly the residence of
Douglas Nesbitt (shoemaker) and Shirley Nesbitt - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1930s
Page 121 of 302
Yonge StreetTemperance StreetReuben
S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 113 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 53 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Queen Anne
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: The Lundy-Clark House
Semi-circular entryway. Various rooflines. Open gables.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Porch, hipped turret feature and
overall form with gables indicates Queen Anne architectural style or
Victorian influenced by Queen Anne. Some unsympathetic
alterations (i.e. squared windows, enclosed porch.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Contsructed c. 1911 by
Nellie D. Lundy and Charles J. Clark. Land acquired by the Lundy
family.
Note: 1921 and 1935 census and voters list indicate that Clark
resided on Yonge Street.
Former residence of Gordon Bell (traveller) and Mrs Galda Bell - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: Early 20th Century
Page 122 of 302
Yonge StreetKennedy
Street
W
e
s
tTemperance StreetReuben
S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 117 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 54 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Altered (unknown)
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Prominent central bay with low pitched
open gable and trifold window opening. Stone quoins, stone
voussoir and lintel. Dual chimney on either side of gabled roof. Stone
exterior on first level. Second storey may have been added later.
Second storey exterior plastered.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: Yes Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Building has been altered (i.e.
likely with the addition of the second storey). May be considered
unique if it can be confirmed that a second storey was added (i.e.
results in a building with two layers of construction)
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: House may have been
relocated. No building shown on 1913 FIP, may have been omitted.
Property sold to Fred Browning (builder) in 1915. Lot described as
vacant in 1916. Increased value in 1917 (Assess. Rolls) 1918 sold to
G.L. Alexander, manager of Imperial Bank 1919 G.L. Alexander sold
to Peter Farris *Browning either built the home, or moved the house.
Former residence of James B. Wilson (merchant), Ella Wilson and
Stuart Wilson (Clerk) - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: Early 20th Century
Page 123 of 302
Kennedy
Street
EastTemperance StreetYonge StreetReuben
S
t
r
e
e
t
Kenned
y
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t
Address: 119 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 55 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1912
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Altered (unknown)
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Wood front porch, side hall entry, bay
window (2 level on side elevation). Pedimented porch roof.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Likely an altered Workers House
(Victorian) with additions, altered window openings.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Frank
bray (printer) and Mary Bray (Nurse's aid) - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 124 of 302
Temperance StreetKenned y
Stre et
East
Reuben
S
t
r
e
e
t
Yonge StreetKennedy
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t
Address: 121 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 56 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Wrap around porch/ verandah with
wooden posts. Open gable with porch overhang.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Workers House, likely influenced
by the Victorian style.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Erma
Stone and Jack Stone (salesman) - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 125 of 302
Kenned
y
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t
Yonge StreetTemperance StreetAddress: 137 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 60 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1908
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Combination
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling and Outbuilding
Heritage Attributes Notes: Front porch with wood columns. Open
gable intersecting with hipped roof. Stone lintels and sills.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Note: LACAC notes describe
construction date as 1908 (1988 document) and 1922 (1995
document) see attached. Needs further confirmation.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1900s
Page 126 of 302
Yonge StreetTemperanceStreetAddress: 139 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 62 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1910
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Medium pitched open gable roof. Low
pitched open gable porch roof. Front porch with brick columns and
wood column supports. Stone foundation.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Representative example of an
Edwardian dwelling.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Murray
Duncan (bus driver) and Ronald Duncan (hospital employee) - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 127 of 302
Yonge StreetRansom
S
t
r
e
e
tTemperance StreetAddress: 143 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 63 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Open gabled roof. Front porch with brick
columns and wood porch supports. Painted stone lintels/ headers
and sills.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 128 of 302
Temperance StreetTyler Str
e
e
t
Address: 56 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 20 Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Original portion of interest located at the
south side with front-end gabled roof. Additions to the north side not
of interest.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Only original portion is considered
an attribute, sympathetic additions at north elevation.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: 1957 Voters list - Thomas
Brodie (hospital attendant), Percy Brodie (tanner), Mrs. Brodie and
1953 voters list - Douglas Case (ice dealer) and Mrs. Case
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1890s
Page 129 of 302
Temperance StreetTyler Str
e
e
t
Address: 58 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 20 Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1858
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Georgian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Open gabled roof, addition. Bay window,
decorative wood surrounds. Side porch, front door overhang. The
Patrick House.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Associated with John
Bowser who became the supervisor of the construction of the Empire
State Building.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1850s
Page 130 of 302
Temperance StreetAddress: 78 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 23 Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Cottage
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Building is no longer a good
representative example of the Gothic revival style. Several window
openings have been enlarged and/or altered, addition at front
elevation, alteration of verandah, front gable and gable arched
window remains. May be possible to remove the unsympathetic
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
None
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Wm.
Rotchell (retired)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: N/A
Page 131 of 302
Temperance StreetAddress: 82 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 23 Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1920
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Bungalow
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Bungalow with overhang roof and porch,
Craftsman style 3/1 windows.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Existing bargeboard likely added
recently, likely new porch and railings.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
None
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 132 of 302
TemperanceStreetAddress: 92 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 23 Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: NA
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Four Square building with centred gable
dormer constructed of angel stone. Enclosed porch. Quoins. Linear
mature trees located on the lot.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Well preserved example of a
stone Edwardian dwelling.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of James
Murby (poultry farmer), Ann Murby (widow) and Mrs. Margaret
Murby - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1900s
Page 133 of 302
TemperanceStreetAddress: 96 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 23 Plan 9
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1910
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Alterations c. 2003. Brick voussoirs. Bay
window on side elevation.
Condition Notes: Building repaired after a fire in 2003.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Removal of original fabric and
features as a result of fire in 2003 has modified the building (including
roof, porch, windows, etc.). No longer a good representative
example.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
None
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 134 of 302
Temperance Street
Address: 100 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 10 Plan 39
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: 19th Century
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Poor
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Classical Cottage (possibly
Georgian), some unsympathetic alterations including alteration of
original window openings.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 39, Surveyed by
P.S. Gibson (Ontario Land Surveyor) for R. J. Kennedy in 1876 (Part of
North half of Lot 79, Concession1, King Twp) and dwellings
constructed between 1879 and the early 20th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Elgin
Kerr (foreman) and Olive Kerr - 1957 as well as Harvey Wright
(stationery engineer) and Peggy Wright.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 135 of 302
Reuben
S
t
r
e
e
tTemperance Street
Address: 102 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 11 Plan 39
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1887
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling and Outbuilding
Heritage Attributes Notes: Philip L. Querrie House
Open gabled roof, bat window, front enclosed porch. Note that
LACAC refers to a Barn (not visible from the street) which may be of
CHVI.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Representative example of a
Victorian "L" shaped dwelling
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Constructed for Philip L.
Querrie (blacksmith) 1887. Purchased by William R. Thompson, who
resided here until 1903. Purchased by the Pinkerton family, sold to a
different William Thompson. Noted as the residence of Myrtle
Newton in 1946.
Former residence of Esther Smith (widow) -1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 136 of 302
Temperance Street
Reuben
S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 104 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 12 Plan 39
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling and Outbuilding
Heritage Attributes Notes: "William Brown House"
Open gabled roof with decorative bargeboard (likely a recent
addition and not original).
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Some removal of original features
and materials. Addition of some unsympathetic features, such as
existing porch railing.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 39, Surveyed by
P.S. Gibson (Ontario Land Surveyor) for R. J. Kennedy in 1876 (Part of
North half of Lot 79, Concession1, King Twp) and dwellings
constructed between 1879 and the early 20th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Likely constructed c. 1889
for William Brown
Tenanted by James A. Knowles (bricklayer) in 1889 and John
Thompson 1891
Former residence of W. Duckenfield (clerk) and Mrs R. Duckenfield -
1957
Note: Unknown if William Brown resided in the house.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: Early 20th Century
Page 137 of 302
TemperanceStreetReuben
S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 108 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 13 Plan 39
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Bungalow
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Pyramid roof. Large chimney.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 39, Surveyed by
P.S. Gibson (Ontario Land Surveyor) for R. J. Kennedy in 1876 (Part of
North half of Lot 79, Concession1, King Twp) and dwellings
constructed between 1879 and the early 20th century.;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 138 of 302
Temperance StreetReuben
S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 110 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 14 Plan 39
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Wrap around porch. Intersecting rooflines.
Angel-stone first level. Corner entryway. Several mature confierfous
trees, linear. Verandah added post 1970.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Possibly Arts and Crafts. Some
alterations have altered the appearance of the dwelling (i.e.
addition of verandah after 1970)
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with Plan 39, Surveyed by
P.S. Gibson (Ontario Land Surveyor) for R. J. Kennedy in 1876 (Part of
North half of Lot 79, Concession1, King Twp) and dwellings
constructed between 1879 and the early 20th century.;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Lionel
Collins (salesman) and Muriel Collins - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: Early 20th Century
Page 139 of 302
Temperance StreetKenned
y
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t
Address: 126 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 46 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1914
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Cuvilnear porch/verandah with wood
columns. Semicircular Bay window with ribbon windows. Original
window openings.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Building constructed in the early 20th
century. Comparison with 1970 aerial detail reveals that some parts
of the building may be later additions (see comparison between
1970 and 2020 aerial).
Moderate
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Associated with Thomas
Swindle (owned the property from 1948 to 1973), leader in
community recreational activities, for whom "Tom's Park" in north-
west Aurora was named.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 140 of 302
Temperance StreetKenned
y
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t
Address: 134 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 44 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Four Square, front porch with wood
classical columns. Stone sills. Large hippped centred bay sunroom.
Wood dentiling details along porch roofline.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Enclosed second storey verandah/sun
porch.
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Hugh
McCrimmon (biologist) and Irene McCrimmon (1957)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: Early 20th Century
Page 141 of 302
Kenned
y
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t
Temperance Street
Address: 138 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 43 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling and Outbuilding
Heritage Attributes Notes: Large front porch with brick columns.
Stone lintels and sills. Two storey read addition. Open gables
intersecting hipped roof. Small stained glass window on front
elevation.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme:
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Charles
A. Fry, Insurance agent (1957)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 20th Century
Page 142 of 302
Ransom
S
t
r
e
e
tTemperance StreetAddress: 142 Temperance Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 42 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1915
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Front porch with brick columns and wood
porch supports. Bay windows on second storey. Stone lintels and sills.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Located along Temperance, part of
the Kennedy Street neighbourhood. Associated with lots subdivided
by Jarvis post 1835 and the mix of urban residential and industrial
land uses.
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Arthur L.
and Olda Coon (retired) - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Kennedy St (Lot 79 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 143 of 302
George StreetAddress: 38 George Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 11 Plan 30
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1910-1920
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Vernacular (Aurora)
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling and Outbuilding
Heritage Attributes Notes: Side hall entry. Open gabled roof. Front
porch. Some alterations include the removal of original materials
and features. House is distinctly different than that of the 1930s and
1940s historical photos with the exception of roof shape, scale/
massing, window and door openings, etc.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Alterations and loss of integrity
results in a building that is no longer representative of this
architectural style.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the Alexandra Park
subdivision (Plan 30) and residential lots created by A. A. Conover
circa 1912, and the buildings constructed between 1912 and the
mid. 20th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Likely under construction by
1921 for Fred Chapman (woodworker, carpenter)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 144 of 302
George StreetAddress: 42 George Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 12 Plan 30
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed:
Date Identified/Listed: 1970s
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling and Outbuilding
Heritage Attributes Notes: Front gabled roof and front porch.
Vernacular or "workers" house, likely new board and batten.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the Alexandra Park
subdivision (Plan 30) and residential lots created by A. A. Conover
circa 1912, and the buildings constructed between 1912 and the
mid. 20th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Likely constructed for John
Wastson c. 1921 (carpenter)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1890s
Page 145 of 302
George StreetAddress: 46 George Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 13 Plan 30
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Bungalow
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling and Outbuilding
Heritage Attributes Notes: Open gabled dormer with wood finial.
Centred entryway with front porch. Cottage 1930s. Clad in vinyl
siding.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: LACAC note: windows altered
and siding added c. 1992. No discernible features indicative of any
architectural style other than a bungalow. Not a "Victory House"
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Under the ownership of John Watson
1921 (Carpenter) (lots 12, 13, and 92). Under the ownership of John
Watson (caretaker) in 1931, owned Lot 13. Building likely constructed
between 1921 and 1931. Douglas Watson (baker) - 1957
None
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Tyler Street (Lot 80 Con 1 West of Yonge St)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 146 of 302
Yonge StreetW ellingto
n
S
t
r
eet W est
Wellingto
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t
Address: 9 Wellington Street East
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 145 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1885
Date Identified/Listed: 1986
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Poor
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Commercial Building
Heritage Attributes Notes: Brick Victorian building with parapet wall.
Dentil brick mouldings along roofline that wraps along the east and
west elevation. Cornicing dividing lower storefront from upper storey.
Semi-circular arched voussoirs are located on the upper window
openings.
Condition Notes: The integrity remains, however, the building
appears to have been ill-maintained over the years causing spalling
bricks and cracks in mortar which would require repair. Brick has
been painted which is deteriorating in areas. Windows and doors
have been replaced (i.e. original shop-front windows and door)
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Commercial Victorian building
with front facade parapet wall and dentil brick mouldings along
roofline. Semi-circular arched voussoirs remain on upper window
openings. Cornicing dividing store front and upper level. Note:
building roof severely damaged by fire in June 2021 (parapet
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with theme of commercial
development in the downtown Commercial core of Aurora and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: The building had been used
as butcher shop for a century. The Knowles Family in particular
owned the building for over 90 years. Butcher shop owners include:
Knowles, Perkins, Caldwell and Tayson. Building constructed by W. J.
Knowles for his business W.J. Knowles & Son Fresh and Salt Meats
which was established in 1881. W.J. Knowles served as a Councillor
for the Town from 1890-1897, 1899-1903, 1905-1906 and Reeve
between 1907-1919 and mayor.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Downtown Aurora (Yonge Street)
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 147 of 302
Wellingt
o
n
Street
WestYonge StreetVictoria StreetWellingto
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t
Address: 21 Wellington Street East
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 148, Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1925
Date Identified/Listed: 1986
Architectural Style/Influence: Period Revival
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: 1925 Georgian Revival or Classical Revival
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the construction of
grand estate homes along Wellington Street in the 19th century;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Constructed by Page &
Warrington of Toronto (distinguished architects). Constructed for
medical doctor, Clifford Devins; Associatd with Devins, former Mayor
and Town Councillor (also see: Devins Orchard).
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: The house is part of a group of three
similar Georgian houses that sit in a row;Recommendation
Major Value - Major Value (and/or) at Risk,
Proritize for Part IV Designation
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Wellington Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 148 of 302
Wellingto
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t
Yonge StreetVictoria StreetAddress: 25 Wellington Street East
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 149 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1950
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Georgian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
None
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: The house is part of a group of three
similar Georgian houses that sit in a row;Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Wellington Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1950s
Page 149 of 302
Victoria StreetWellingt
o
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t
Address: 35-37 Wellington Street East
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1903
Date Identified/Listed: 1986
Architectural Style/Influence: Vernacular (Aurora)
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Associated with Dr.
Crawford Rose who resided in the house from 1926 - 1946 and served
on Town Council as well as the Mayor of Aurora;
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Wellington Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1900s
Page 150 of 302
Wellingto
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t
Victoria StreetWells Street
Address: 49 Wellington Street East
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 1 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1905
Date Identified/Listed: 1986
Architectural Style/Influence: Vernacular (Aurora)
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Wellington Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1900s
Page 151 of 302
Wellingto
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
tWells StreetNorthWells Street
Address: 61 Wellington Street East
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 5 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1858
Date Identified/Listed: 1986
Architectural Style/Influence: Georgian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes: Front brick addition or covering of porch
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Wellington Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1850s
Page 152 of 302
Wells StreetLarmont StreetWellingto
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t
Address: 81 Wellington Street East
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 10 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1858
Date Identified/Listed: 1986
Architectural Style/Influence: Vernacular (Aurora)
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes: Thought to have been originally a Georgian house
converted.
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Wellington Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1850s
Page 153 of 302
Larmont StreetWellingto
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t
Address: 85 Wellington Street East
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 11 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1855
Date Identified/Listed: 1986
Architectural Style/Influence: Ontario Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes: Covered in aluminium siding.
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Wellington Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1850s
Page 154 of 302
WaltonDrive
Wellingt
o
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t
Larmont StreetAddress: 89 Wellington Street East
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 12 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1883
Date Identified/Listed: 1986
Architectural Style/Influence: Ontario Cottage
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Wellington Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 155 of 302
WaltonDriveWellingto
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t
Larmont StreetAddress: 91 Wellington Street East
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 13 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1913
Date Identified/Listed: 1986
Architectural Style/Influence: American Foursquare
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Wellington Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 156 of 302
Walton DriveWellingt
o
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t
Larmont StreetBerczy StreetAddress: 99 Wellington Street East
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 15 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1915
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Vernacular (Aurora)
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Wellington Street
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 157 of 302
Victoria StreetMosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Yonge StreetTyler Str
e
e
t
Address: 11-13 Mosley Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 5 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1911
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees. Adaptively reused.
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Edwardian with Queen Anne
influences - combination of brick and stone.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Moderate
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Constructed in 1910-1911 for
George Lemon (hotel keeper), about to retire from his business
(located around the corner, known as the Royal Hotel). Possibly
constructed by G.T. Browning. House resided in by Eva Lemon until
her death in 1957, and tenated the house. Adaptively re-used as an
office building in the 1970s.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 158 of 302
Victoria StreetMosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 23 Mosley Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 3 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1855
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Georgian
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Building
Heritage Attributes Notes: "Campbell-Fleury House". Altered dwelling,
now commercial. Large contemporary addition.
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area.
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Removal of features which are
important in communicating the classic Georgian style (raised
roofline, addition of gable, etc.) Building now reads as a Gothic
Cottage rather than its original Georgian style.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: historical development of the 1854
Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and buildings constructed in the
mid. to late 19th century;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: John and William Campbell
carried on the Yonge Street ropemaking business established by
their father, John Campbell. William Campbell died in the house in
1886. William's sister Isabella Lang took over the property and gave it
to her daughter Henrietta Fleury and her husband Milton Fleury.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1850s
Page 159 of 302
Victoria StreetMosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 37 Mosley Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 6 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1865
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Altered (unknown)
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1860s
Page 160 of 302
Victoria StreetMosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 41 Mosley Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 7 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1870s
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Revival
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Poor
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Stucco clad
Condition Notes: Issues with stucco cladding - visible deterioration.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Removal of majority of original
materials. Overall form remains with modified window and door
openings.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: 1957 - residence of Victor
Attridge (retired contractor) resided on Yonge Street in 1921 (Aurora
census)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 161 of 302
Mosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Victoria StreetWells Street
Address: 43 Mosley Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 8 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Regency
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Original features and materials
removed. building retains overall roof shape and 3-bay facade
typical of a Regency dwelling.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Difficulty in confirming the
construction date of the house (See attached documentation). W.
Atkinson sold Lot 8 to Annette Allen for $650.00, which may have
included a modest dwelling.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 19th Century
Page 162 of 302
Mosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Wells StreetVictoria StreetAddress: 49 Mosley Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 10 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1870s
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Building retains scale, window
openings, gable feature.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former home of Wm.
Pattenden and D.A. Pattenden (shoemaker) 1957.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 163 of 302
Larmont StreetMosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 91 Mosley Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 20 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1915
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: 1957 - Home of Mrs. Ed Allen
(widow)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 164 of 302
Larmont StreetMosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 95 Mosley Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 20 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1911
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Sympathetic alterations.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Constructed by Dalton
Richardson, rented in 1912 to the stationmaster. Owned by the
Richardson family until 1977.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 165 of 302
LarmontStreetMosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Berczy StreetAddress: 103 Mosley Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN): 036500074
Map
Legal Description: Lt 11 W/s Berczy St Pl 68 Aurora; Lt 12 W/s Berczy St
Pl 68 Aurora; Lt 13 W/s Berczy St Pl 68 Aurora; Lt 14 W/s Berczy St Pl 68
Aurora; Lt 15 W/s Berczy St Pl 68 Aurora ; Aurora
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: post 1927
Date Identified/Listed: 1977
Architectural Style/Influence: 19th Century
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Poor
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Building
Heritage Attributes Notes: Industrial building, Sisman-Underhill
Factory, Sisman Shoes, formerly Micro Wire Products, Plan 68 Part Lots
7-15 (formerly 36 Berczy Street). Existing portion of the building
constructed post 1927. Early portions of the building were
constructed in the early 1900s and removed in 1982.
Condition Notes: Visible masonry issues.
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Representative example of an
early 20th century industrial building (remnant of the former factory)
constructed after 1927.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) in part
of Lot 80, Concession 1 EYS. Associated with the industrial base and/
or development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood.
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Thomas Sisman, noted as a
prominent member of Aurora (obituary, 1933). Sons Wililam and J
and Herbert both served as members of Council. Sisman Shoe
Factory was a major local employer.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Located on part of the 1854 John
Mosley subdivision. The main portions of the former factory have all
been demolished. Only the office building remains. T. Sisman resided
across the street from the factory on Mosley Street (demolished). The
shoe factory was employed by many local residents within the
SEHCD area and therefore has a historical relationship with the
property.
Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1930s
Page 166 of 302
LarmontStreetBerczy StreetMosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 34-38 Berczy Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 7 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Other
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Commercial Building
Heritage Attributes Notes: Property includes two separate buildings
(34 and 38 Berczy). Facades altered to re-purpose industrial use for
commercial use. Alterations include: stucco covering decorative
brickwork. Originally constructed in the Industrial/Functional style.
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Heritage integrity of both
buildings has been diminished.
None
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: YesSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the industrial base
and/or development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood.
Major
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Associated with Underhill
and Sisman Shoe Manufacturing Company. The building at 34
Berczy was used to produce shoes from 1901 to the 1970's. The
building at 38 Berczy does not appear on the 1904 rev. 1927 FIP and
was constructed afterwards. Both buildings appear on the 1960 FIP.
The building at what is now 38 Berczy is noted as a concrete
building.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: The historical use of the building as
one of the primary industrial operations in Aurora supports the
character of the area. The history of the building contributed to the
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood which
links the building to its surroundings.
Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1900s
Page 167 of 302
Victoria StreetMosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 22 Mosley Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 2 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1876
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Neo-Classical
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former home of Wyatt and
Lydia Baldwin (pharmacist) 1957. Owned by members of the Baldwin
family for over 100 years. Sold to George Baldwin in 1889. George
Baldwin operated a family flower fill in Laskay until 1887, then
purchased the Irwin Mill in Aurora and resided on the mill property
(now demolished).The Baldwins are noted as being active in local
politics and leading Businessmen. George Baldwin was elected to
Council, and served as reeve.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: Yes
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 168 of 302
Victoria StreetMosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 40 Mosley Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 6 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1911
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Well mainted example of Workers
Housing. Dwelling likely includes some Romanesque or Queen Anne
influences.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Likely originally included a
dwelling constructed between 1882 and 1888 for Wm J. Ward.
Purchased by Richard Tustain in 1912. 1911 Aurora Banner article
notes that Richard Tustin purchased a property with a dwelling from
the Smyth Estate. Existing dwelling likely an entirely new building
constructed c. 1911. Later the residence of Howard Bunn, retired
shoemaker.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 169 of 302
Wells Street
Mosley S
t
r
e
e
tVictoria StreetAddress: 48 Mosley Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 9 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1873
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Attached documentation
identifies that the house was likely constructed during the ownership
of William C. Oliver (carriage maker). Property value was assessed at
$400.00 in 1873, and sold for $1,725.00 in 1874. Property subsequently
tenanted. Property sold to David Fotheringham (local school
inspector) in 1886. Subsequently sold to Mary Proctor.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 170 of 302
Wells Street
Mosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 52 Mosley Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 9 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1874
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Cottage
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Good example of Gothic revival cottage.
Sympathetic alterations.
Condition Notes: Renovated/updated
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Assessment rolls indicate
that the property value decreased between 1868 and 1873 under
the ownership of John MacKay, where the property was likely
vacant. Subsequent owner William C. Oliver (carriage maker)
purchased the property in 1873 for $400.00. Property sold in 1874 for
$1725.00.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
None
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 171 of 302
WellsStreet Larmont StreetMosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 80 Mosley Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1874
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Ontario Cottage
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes: Original stone foundation covered with stucco.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Removal of some attributes -
possibly Ontario Cottage which has been altered. Possibly older than
c.1900.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Likely constructed by W.
Atkinson in 1874, for Thomas Atkin (or Atkins). Property sold to David
Foster in 1882. Sold to Enoch Chandler in 1883, who owned the
property until 1910. The dwelling was likely remodeled in the 1890s,
accounting for the unusual steep gable (second floor may have
been added at this time). Chandler worked at the Fleury Foundry.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
None
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 172 of 302
Victoria StreetMetcalfe
Street
Gurnett StreetYonge StreetChurch S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 13 Church Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1875
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees in rear yard. Dwelling was
originally constructed of wood frame, covered over with Insulbrick. In
1985 it was removed and new wood cladding was applied.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with historical residential
development and the creation of Plan of Subdivision by John Mosley
(Plan 68) which was registered after Richard Machell’s Plan in 1853;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Associated with the
Holman/Fray family. 1935 Voters list - Joseph Holman (shoemaker) on
Centre Street. Hert T. Holman (dairyman) on Centre Street.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 173 of 302
Victoria StreetGurnett Street
Harriso nAvenue
Metcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
t
Yonge StreetChurch S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 17 Church Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 1 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1880
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with historical residential
development and the creation of Plan of Subdivision by John Mosley
(Plan 68) which was registered after Richard Machell’s Plan in 1853;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 174 of 302
GurnettStreetVictoria StreetYongeStreetHarr iso n Avenu e
Metcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
t
Church S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 21 Church Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 2 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed:
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Bungalow
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with historical residential
development and the creation of Plan of Subdivision by John Mosley
(Plan 68) which was registered after Richard Machell’s Plan in 1853;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1900s
Page 175 of 302
Victoria StreetMetcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
t
Church S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 33 Church Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 4 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1895
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: May be an earlier building that was
altered. Original brick facade covered in stucco.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
None
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1890s
Page 176 of 302
Victoria StreetChurch S
t
r
e
e
t
Metcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 37 Metcalfe Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 2 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.19870
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Georgian
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Ethel
Hacking (widow) - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 177 of 302
GurnettStreetVictoria StreetChurch
Street
Wells StreetMetcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 43 Metcalfe Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 4 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1875
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Some removal of original
materials and features. Overall built form, gables, window and door
openings remain.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former home of Erastus
Harman (foreman)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 178 of 302
Victoria StreetWells StreetMetcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 47 Metcalfe Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 5 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1915-1920
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: 19th Century
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Variation of Edwardian with
gambrel roofline, making it distinctive from other variations in Aurora
(not rare or unique in in the context of Aurora or Ontario)
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Lot owned by Simeon Russel
1877. Unlikely a building was constructed at this time, likely that
Simeon did not reside on the lot. Lot owned by Basil Hobday c. 1888
(1893?) Sold in 1919 by Lena Hobday (sold to tenant)? to the Patrick
family (labourer by occupation, see 1940 voters list). Former
residence of Donald Patrick (labourer) and S.G. Patrick (merchant)
and Mrs. Patrick - 1957.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 179 of 302
Wells StreetMetcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 51 Metcalfe Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 6 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed:
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees located on the property.
Condition Notes: Significantly altered.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme:
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: Yes
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1890s
Page 180 of 302
Wells StreetMetcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 53 Metcalfe Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 7 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1925
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees, hip roof, dormer, rear
addition.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Ward
Hoffman (designer) and Mrs. Ward - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: No
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 181 of 302
Wells StreetMetcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 59 Metcalfe Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 10 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1915
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: mature trees present on lot
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Hugh A.
Bowman (insurance) and Mrs. Bowman - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 182 of 302
Wells StreetMetcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 61 Metcalfe Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 10 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Poor
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Majority of original materials have
been removed. Overall scale/massing and window and door
openings remain.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Sold by John Kendall to
John and Rebecca Mabley c. 1880. (retired farmers). Sold to Milton
Whiteoak in 1907 (moulder). Former residence of F.C. Copson
(retired) -1957.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 183 of 302
LarmontStreetMetcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
t
Edward StreetAddress: 83 Metcalfe Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 16 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1910
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Alterations have reduced
integrity, no longer a representative example of this style
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Forms a "pair" with 85 Metcalfe Street,
adjacent. Likely constructed by Herb Lennox, who purchased lots on
Metcalfe with the intent to construct six houses in the summer of
1910.
Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 184 of 302
LarmontStreetMetcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
t
Edward StreetAddress: 85 Metcalfe Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1910
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Alterations have reduced
integrity, no longer a representative example of this style
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Forms a "pair" with 83 Metcalfe Street,
adjacent. Likely constructed by Herb Lennox, who purchased lots on
Metcalfe with the intent to construct six houses in the summer of
1910.
Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 185 of 302
LarmontStreetMetcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
t
Edward Street
Address: 87 Metcalfe Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 16 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1910
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Alterations have reduced
integrity, no longer a representative example of this style
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Forms a "pair" with 89 Metcalfe,
adjacent. Likely constructed by Herb Lennox, who purchased lots on
Metcalfe with the intent to construct six houses in the summer of
1910.
Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 186 of 302
LarmontStreetMetcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
t
Edward Street
Address: 89 Metcalfe Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 17 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1910
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Alterations have reduced
integrity, no longer a representative example of this style.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Visually linked to building adjacent -
forms a "pair" at 87 Metcalfe. Likely constructed by Herb Lennox,
who purchased lots on Metcalfe with the intent to construct six
houses in the summer of 1910.
Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 187 of 302
LarmontStreetMetcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
t
Edward StreetAddress: 91 Metcalfe Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 17 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1910
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Alterations have reduced
integrity, no longer a representative example of this style.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Linked to building located adjacent,
which forms a "pair" at 93 Metcalfe. Likely constructed by Herb
Lennox, who purchased lots on Metcalfe with the intent to construct
six houses in the summer of 1910.
Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 188 of 302
Metcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
tLarmontStreet
Edward Street
Address: 93 Metcalfe Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 18 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1910
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Alterations have reduced
integrity, no longer a representative example of this style. Stone
veneer added pre 1981 to first storey.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: No
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: "pairs" of buildings along the street, i.e.
91 Metcalfe. Likely constructed by Herb Lennox, who purchased lots
on Metcalfe with the intent to construct six houses in the summer of
1910.
Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 189 of 302
Metcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
tLarmontStreet
Edward Street
Address: 97 Metcalfe Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 19 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1890
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Some removal of heritage
attributes - overall built form remains
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1890s
Page 190 of 302
Berczy StreetMe tcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
t
EdwardStreetAddress: 107 Metcalfe Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 22 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1888
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Revival
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Poor
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Removal of original fabric and
some heritage attributes has reduced integrity. Building retains
overall scale, massing, built form, window and door openings.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: 1886 - Samuel Edwards.
1902 - Ezrs. J. Fleury. 1911 - George Obee, railway worker (note 1921
census places G. Obee on Larmont Street). Annie Edwards - 1924.
(see title attached)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 191 of 302
Edward StreetMetcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
tLarmont StreetAddress: 90 Metcalfe Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 14 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1880s
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Majority of original materials have
been removed. Style is discernible from front gable, window and
door openings, scale and massing.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Formerly under the
ownerships of Albert Davis, Atwood bates, Edwin Cross, and Ms.
Williams. 1957 - home of A.J. Blanchard (road master)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 192 of 302
Me t calfe
S
t
r
e
e
t
EdwardSt
ree
t Berczy StreetLarmont StreetAddress: 102 Metcalfe Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 17 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1886
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees located on the property.
Known as the "Joseph Davis House".
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Removal of original materials and
re-clad. Dwelling retains overall scale/mass and built form as well as
window and door openings.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Joseph David - (carpenter)
Walter E. Davis (Baldwin Flour mill)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 193 of 302
Edward S
treet Berczy StreetMetcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
tLarmont StreetAddress: 106 Metcalfe Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 19 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1920
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Some removal of original
features. Retains overall built form and window and door openings.
Existing front vernadah was likely added later (see footprint on FIP).
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former home of P.G. and
Mrs. Barwick ("Town employee:) formerly worked at the Sisman shoe
factory
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 194 of 302
Gurnett StreetHarrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 41 Harrison Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 79 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1922
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Craftsman
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 195 of 302
Gurnett StreetWells StreetHarrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 43 Harrison Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 77 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed:
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Colonial Revival
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Possibly a Catalogue order house
(i.e. Sears, etc.)
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Significant Theme:
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1940s
Page 196 of 302
WellsStreetHarrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 47 Harrison Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 75 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1912
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 197 of 302
Wells Street
Harrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 51 Harrison Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 73 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1916
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Arts and Crafts
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Home of local lumber
dealer and cabinet maker (Samuel George).
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 198 of 302
Wel
ls
StreetHarrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 55 Harrison Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 67 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1929
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Bungalow
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: Early 20th Century
Page 199 of 302
Wells
StreetHarrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 57 Harrison Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 67 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1921
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Craftsman
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees. Likely reclad with stucco.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 200 of 302
Harrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Wells Street
Address: 73 Harrison Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 57 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1910 - 1920
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Rear mature trees. Contemporary
windows
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Note that building is similar to that
of the building located at 85 Harrison Avenue and were likely
constructed at the same time.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Lot 57 purchased by Ontario
Homes Ltd. in 1912. Building likely constructed by Ontario Homes Ltd.
and sold to Albert A. Conover. Note: Albert Conover noted in 1921
census of Aurora as a farmer residing on Tyler Street.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 201 of 302
Harrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Wells StreetEdward StreetAddress: 77 Harrison Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 55 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1930
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Bungalow
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Pebble Dash clad. Mature trees. "Edward
Holder House 1930"
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Constructed c.1930 for
Edward and Eva Holder (occupation unknown). Former residence of
H.W. Mason (hydro worker) and Mrs Mason - 1957.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1930s
Page 202 of 302
Edward StreetHarrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 81 Harrison Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 53 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1920 - 1930
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Bungalow
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees. Clad in stucco.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 203 of 302
Edward StreetHarrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 85 Harrison Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 51 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1920
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature tree.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of J.M.
Curran (painter) and Mrs Curran - 1957.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 204 of 302
VictoriaStreetGurnett Street
Harrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 40 Harrison Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 48 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1910
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees. Many original windows and
attributes remain. Queen Anne or Edwardian with Queen Anne
influences (i.e Queen Anne style parlour windows).
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. lots located along Harrison
Avenue) and buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former home of Reginald A.
Fraser. Note that 1921 census places Fraser on Mosley Street. 1935
Voters list places Mrs. Fraser (widow) on Harrison.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 205 of 302
Harrison
A
v
e
n
u
e Wel
ls
StreetGurnettStreetVictoria StreetAddress: 44 Harrison Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 47 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1927
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees. original features retained.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Very well preserved example of a
grand Edwardian variation
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. lots located along Harrison
Avenue) and buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: likely constructed c. 1927 for
Ernest Glass and Elizabeth Glass (Assessment notes increase in value
between 1915 and 1927).
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 206 of 302
GurnettStreetHarrison
A
v
e
n
u
e Wells StreetVictoria StreetAddress: 48 Harrison Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 46 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Arts and Crafts
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees. New distressed cladding
(board and batten).
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Addition of board and batten
confuses this architectural style with Workers Housing or another
vernacular Victorian style.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. lots located along Harrison
Avenue) and buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 207 of 302
Wells StreetHarrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 68 Harrison Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 38 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1922
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Craftsman
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees. Dwelling clad with pebble
dash.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Craftsman or Arts and Crafts
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. lots located along Harrison
Avenue) and buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of William
Pattenden (mason) (1923) *Note: Wm. Pattenden resided on
Larmont St. in 1921. Former residence of Mildred Weir, nurse (1957)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 208 of 302
Wells StreetHarrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 72 Harrison Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 37 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1922
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Craftsman
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees. Stucco clad.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. lots located along Harrison
Avenue) and buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former home of Samuel
Atkinson (carpenter)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 209 of 302
Wells StreetHarrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 76 Harrison Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 36 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1920s
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. lots located along Harrison
Avenue) and buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 210 of 302
Harrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
EdwardStreetAddress: 80 Harrison Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 35 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1920
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Original windows and attributes retained.
Mature trees.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 211 of 302
Harrison
A
v
e
n
u
e Edward StreetAddress: 84 Harrison Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 34 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1913
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event:Significant Person:
Significant Activity:Significant Organization/Institution:
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. lots located along Harrison
Avenue) and buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Likely the home of Albert
Barr, 1913
Hans Kaudse, 1915
James Walley, 1920
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 212 of 302
Harrison
A
v
e
n
u
e Edward StreetAddress: 92 Harrison Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 32 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Rear and side additions. Unsympathetic
front porch (enclosed after 1981).
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. lots located along Harrison
Avenue) and buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 213 of 302
Harrison
A
v
e
n
u
e Edward StreetAddress: 100 Harrison Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 29 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1930
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Arts and Crafts
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees located on the property.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. lots located along Harrison
Avenue) and buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Note: No resident noted at
100 Harrison in 1957 Voters List
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1930s
Page 214 of 302
Gurnett StreetKenn e dy
S treet
E
a
s
t
Connaug
h
t
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 35 Connaught Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 101 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1930
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature tree. Sympathetic additions.
contemporary windows.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Some alterations have resulted in
removal of original features and fabric. Likely an altered example of
Workers Housing with a large rear addition.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1930s
Page 215 of 302
Gurnett Street
Connaug
h
t
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 37 Connaught Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 100 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1930
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Craftsman
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature tree. Possibly oroginal wood
windows retained at street. Large yet symparhetic rear addition.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1930s
Page 216 of 302
Wells Street
Connaug
h
t
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 47 Connaught Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 97 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1915
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature tree
Condition Notes: Likely contemporary cladding over wood frame or
brick.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Formerly owned by Hudson
Bowman (tanner by occupation) in 1913, employed at Collis tannery
west of Yonge Street. Subsequently owned by Amelia Heakes
(widow). Sold to Mr. Peter Bovair (retired farmers). After the death of
Peter Bovair, house was tenanted. Sold to Geore A. Teasdale and
Laura Teasdale in 1942.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 217 of 302
Wells Street
Connaug
h
t
A
v
e nue
Address: 51 Connaught Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 96 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1925
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Craftsman
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees present on the property.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 218 of 302
Connaug
h
t
A
v
e
n
u
e
Wells
Street
Address: 71 Connaught Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 89 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1925
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Arts and Crafts
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Note: Contemporary windows, original
windows removed. Existing windows in a similar style as Craftsman/
Arts & Crafts.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former home of Ada and
Norman Johnson (school principal) (1957). Prominent Citizens, Norm
is a member of the Aurora Hall of Fame. Ada was one of the first
female doctors.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 219 of 302
Connaug
h
t
A
v
e
n
u
e
WellsStreetAddress: 75 Connaught Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 88 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Arts and Crafts
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees present on the property.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of William
H. and Mrs. William H. Case, Insurance broker - 1957.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 220 of 302
Edward StreetConnau
g
h
t
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 85 Connaught Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 85 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1915
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees. Painted brick.
Contemporary windows. Sympathetically altered.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Likely constructed by Edgar
W. Andrews (woodworker) in 1915. Property sold in 1921 to Preston M.
Thompson (who owned a furniture business). Purchased by W.E.
Griffits in 1928. Purchased by Floyd E. Corner in 1951.Former
residence of W.J Dinner (sheet metal worker), as well as D. and Mrs
Dinner - 1957 (may have been tenants).
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 221 of 302
Gurnett StreetConnaug
h
t
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 36 Connaught Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 82 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1930
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Vernacular (Aurora)
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature tree. contemporary windows.
Building clad with stucco - cannot confirm if stucco is original.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Frank
and Sylvia Grainger (1930s). Later owned by Alex J. Annan
(gentleman) and Mary Annan (teacher) (see 1957 voters list).
Property later purchased by the Bootsmans.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1930s
Page 222 of 302
Gurnett StreetConnaug
h
t
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 40 Connaught Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 80 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: C.1925
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Altered (unknown)
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature tree. Alterations and addition at
front facade.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Building, when viewed from the
sides shows brick, arched window openings, and evidence of a
verandah which has been enclosed and clad with existing wood
shingles. Possibly an altered Craftsman style building.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of H.E.
Frankcom (service station worker) and Mrs. Frankcom - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 223 of 302
Connaug
h
t
A venue Wells StreetGurnett StreetAddress: 44 Connaught Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 78 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: Pre 1927
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Craftsman
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Poor
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of E.
Cambridge (mechanic) and Mrs. Cambridge - 1957. See attached
article by Keith Kincaid, former resident during the 1940s.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 224 of 302
Conn a ught
A
v
e
n
u
e Wells StreetAddress: 52 Connaught Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 74 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1914
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees. Contemporary windows.
Sympathetic additions.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Good example of an Edwardian
dwelling which retains the majority of its heritage attributes.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Wm. R.
Kinnear (civil engineer) and Mrs. Kinnear - 1957. Constructed 1914 by
Lewis Stephens (no evidence that Lewis Stephens is significant to the
community as a builder). Tenanted in 1915 by C.F. Ewers, who
replaced the Principal at Aurora High School. Purchased in 1961 by
John and Mary Frances O'Mahony.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1930s
Page 225 of 302
Wells Street
Harrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Connaug
h
t
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 68 Connaught Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 60 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1931
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Arts and Crafts
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees. Possibly reclad with stucco
over brick.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Earl
Attridge (lumber merchant) - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1930s
Page 226 of 302
Wel
l
sStreetHarrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Connaug
h
t
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 72 Connaught Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 58 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: Post 1927
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees. Likely stucco clad over brick.
Roofline has likely been altered. Unsympathetic gable window
above second storey. Stucco likely not original.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of C.C.
Patterson (operator) 1957.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: Early 20th Century
Page 227 of 302
Edward StreetHarrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Wel
ls StreetConnau
g
h
t
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 76 Connaught Avenue
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 56 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1913
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees. Some contemporary
windows. Unknown if iron fence is original or later addition.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Vacant lot purchased by
Charles H. Andrews in 1912. House likely constructed 1913. Andrews
worked at the Fleury Plough Works on Wellington Street West. C.
Andrews died in 1930. Lot was sold to George Schell in 1922 (retired
gentleman). Owned by John and Grave Morrow in 1946. J Morrow
operated a service station. Property sold to Miss Mary Walker (nurse)
and Miss Martha Walker (nurse) in 1953.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 228 of 302
Yonge StreetGurnett StreetReuben
Street
Connaug
h
t
Avenue
Kennedy
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t
Address: 8 Kennedy Street East
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 162 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed:
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Cottage
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Poor
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees. Removal of features and
unsympathetic alterations. No longer representative example of the
Gothic Cottage style.
Notes provided in Archives file indicate house may have been
constructed as early as 1825. Note: given that the dwelling is
constructed of brick, it is unlikely that this is the case. Original building
(possibly under brick) may be constructed of logs.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Building likely constructed prior to
1867 (based on available research).
Major
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Note: building may predate John Mosleys Plan
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: Mid. 19th Century
Page 229 of 302
Cameron
Avenue
Royal R
o
a
d
Address: 42 Royal Road
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 14 Plan 487
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Altered (unknown)
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees. Additions in board and
batten. House is located at an angle to the street.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Original portion of building
estimated by LACAC to be constructed in the 1860s. Original portion
of the building is not visible. Extent of alterations and additions has
diminished the integrity of the building.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
None
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: 1954 aerial photo suggests
this may be the location of a former horse farm (race track formerly
included on the property). Needs further confirmation.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
None
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: No
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Not part of the Southeast Old Aurora
neighbourhood. Formerly part of what is likely a farm complex which
included a race track in 1954 (see aerial photo). The farm complex
was removed between 1954 and 1970 and subdivided to become
the existing residential neighbourhood. The historical, functional and
physical link to its surroundings has been removed.
Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s):
Neighbourhood Group: N/A
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 19th Century
Page 230 of 302
Yonge StreetGurnett StreetConnaug
h
t
Avenue
Reuben
S
t
r
e
e
t
Kennedy
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t
Address: 15037 Yonge Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 166 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1900
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees. Adaptively reused as
commercial.
Condition Notes: Contemporary windows
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1900s
Page 231 of 302
Gurnett StreetYonge StreetKenned
y
S
t
r
e
e
t
W
e
s
t
Kennedy
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t
Address: 15029 Yonge Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 167 Plan 246
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1925
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Arts and Crafts
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees and cobblestone wall.
Converted to seniors residence. Additions and alterations.
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 232 of 302
Edward
S
t
r
e
e
t
Allaura Boulevard
Address: 95 Allaura Boulevard
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 77, Con 1 East of Yonge Street
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Georgian
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling and Outbuilding
Heritage Attributes Notes: Graham-Wood House. Mature linear trees
along exterior property line along Allaura. Mature trees (potentially
oak) throughout property. Georgian house with plastered exterior.
Small barn with metal gambrel roof and brick chimney.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Dwelling was likely constructed in
the mid. to late 19th century. Buildings not depicted on the 1860
Tremaine Map. Building appears on the 1878 Map of Whitchurch
Twp.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Moderate
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Associated with the
Graham family (1798 - 1912) and the Wood family (1912 - 1973).
Adaptively re-used for commercial/industrial. Noted by LACAC as
owned by the Municipality during the 1980s. Title records (attached)
confirm that the lot was patented from the Crown to Capt. Wm.
Graham in 1798. The lot was transferred to Peter Graham in 1848,
then to Adam Graham in 1858, to Alfred Graham in 1874. *Farm
shown on 1878. Transferred to Boyle in 1880.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: No
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: No longer an agricultural landscape,
has been severed to result in a small lot and has been adaptively re-
used. Is not contributing to the existing context but is historically
linked to its surroundings.
Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group:
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: Mid. 19th Century
Page 233 of 302
WellsStreet
Victoria StreetAddress: 33 Victoria Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1909
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Large front addition (mid. 20th century)
Alterations to suit adaptive re-use (funeral home)
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: YesSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Moderate
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Longstanding Aurora
business: Thompson Funeral Home (see 1960 FIP detail). Associated
with the Sheppard, Butler, Underhill (George Earl?) families. Frank
Underhill (occupation, insurance) 1957 Voters list.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1900s
Page 234 of 302
Mosley S
t
r
e
e
tVictoria StreetAddress: 37 Victoria Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1886
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Modest Victorian dwelling, likely a
vernacular Workers Housing variation. Some removal of original
features. Overall scale/massing, roofline, window and door openings
remain.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: "The Willis House".
Constructed by Milton Cummer. John F. Willis (Stone cutter? store
owner?).
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 235 of 302
Victoria StreetMosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 63 Victoria Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 5 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Georgian
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees. "William Andres House c
1860"
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Removal of original windows.
Roof window added. Shutters not original. Contemporary windows.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Constructed between 1860
and 1879 by either Henry Danbrook or James Andrews.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 236 of 302
Mosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Victoria StreetAddress: 67 Victoria Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 5 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1911
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees. Contemporary windows.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former home of Clarence
Jebb, Barber (1957)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 237 of 302
Victoria StreetMetcalfe
Street
GurnettStreetHarrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 89 Victoria Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 1 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1890
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1890s
Page 238 of 302
Wellingto
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t
Victoria StreetAddress: 20 Victoria Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 1 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1880
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area.
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: "York Wilcox House". James
Dudley Wilcox - General Merchant (1921). Wilcox family associated
with the property from 1879-1963.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 239 of 302
Victoria StreetAddress: 28 Victoria Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 3 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: pre. 1913
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Bungalow
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Porch has been enclosed.
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Enclosed porch and removal of
original attributes has diminished integrity.
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: 1957 - home of Dwight and
Anne Hess (Pharmacist).
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 240 of 302
Victoria StreetAddress: 32 Victoria Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 4 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Period Revival
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Example of an early to mid. 20th
century Period Revival building (possibly Sears catalogue home)
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
None
Significant Theme:
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: Early 20th Century
Page 241 of 302
Mosley S
t
r
e
e
tVictoria StreetAddress: 36 Victoria Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 5 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Altered (unknown)
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Good example of a 1920s era
bungalow.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Moderate
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Home of the Knowles family
(i.e. Butcher at 9 Wellington St. E). Property remained owned by
members of the COckerill/Knowles family from 1919-1987. Last owner
(Paul Knowles) from 1954-1987 (not employed as a butcher).
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 242 of 302
Victoria StreetMosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 40 Victoria Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 2 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1930
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Bungalow
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Moderate
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Likely constructed for Freda
and Nixon Fisher - merchant (occupation)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1930s
Page 243 of 302
GurnettStreetVictoria StreetHa rris o nAven ue
Metcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
t
Church S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 80 Victoria Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1885
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Building includes "hip on gable" or
"jerkin head" roof at front elevation
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 244 of 302
Victoria StreetGurnettStreetMetcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
t
Ha rris o n
A
v
e
n
ue
Church S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 84 Victoria Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1885
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Georgian
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Stucco and re-clad
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 245 of 302
VictoriaStreetGurnett StreetHarri s on
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 91 Gurnett Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1880
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Cottage
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees located on the property.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with historical residential
development and the creation of Plan of Subdivision by John Mosley
(Plan 68) which was registered fter Richard Machell’s Plan in 1853;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 246 of 302
VictoriaStreetGurnettStreetHarri s on
A
venue
Address: 95 Gurnett Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 9 Plan 1B
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1900
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees
Condition Notes: Removal of many original atributes. Possibly workers
house.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1900s
Page 247 of 302
Gurnett Street
H a rrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 97 Gurnett Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 8 Plan 1B
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Bungalow
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature tree
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: Early 20th Century
Page 248 of 302
H arri son
A
v
e
n
u
e
Gurnett StreetAddress: 99 Gurnett Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 7 Plan 1B
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1910
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: New or renovated verandah.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: Yes
Supports the Character of the Area: No
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 249 of 302
Harr i son
A
v enue
Gurnett StreetAddress: 101 Gurnett Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 6 Plan 1B
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1860
Date Identified/Listed: 1978
Architectural Style/Influence: Ontario Cottage
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Moderate
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Built by M. Gurnett of
Aurora.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Similar to adjacent 103 Gurnett.Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1860s
Page 250 of 302
Gurnett StreetConnaug
h
t
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 107 Gurnett Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Plan 1B
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1910
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Contemporary windows and alterations.
Mature trees. Included as a revision on the 1904 FIP. Therefore, the
building was constructed bet. 1904 and 1913. Note that historical
photo confirms stucco is original.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 251 of 302
HarrisonAvenue
Yonge StreetGurnett StreetAddress: 96 Gurnett Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 9 Plan 1B
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1875
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Late Victorian
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: 1 1/2 storey fram, gable roof and gable
front, bay window
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Worker's housing.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Rental housing for local labourers.
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 252 of 302
Har
r
isonAven
ue
YongeStreetGurnett StreetAddress: 100 Gurnett Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 7 Plan 1B
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed:
Date Identified/Listed: c. 1868
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Contemporary windows and cladding.
Mature tree.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Early residential development.
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: John T. Gurnett had this built
as a worker’s house in conjunction with tannery due NW on Yonge
Street.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1860s
Page 253 of 302
YongeStreetGurnett StreetAddress: 102 Gurnett Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 6 Plan 1B
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1855
Date Identified/Listed: 1982
Architectural Style/Influence: Ontario Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: 1 1/2 storey stucco, gable roof and
verandah.
Condition Notes: Contemporary windows a d cladding.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Early Ontario Cottage with
verandah
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Early residential development.
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1850s
Page 254 of 302
LarmontStreetWells Street
Address: 31 Wells Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1875
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Regency
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Majority of heritage attributes
and materials have been removed.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century; Possibly
constructed by William Atkinson, for Frederick Long.
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: First resident of 31 Wells was
Frederick Long who purchased the property from William Atkinson in
1872. Unknown conclusively if W. Atkinson constructed the property.
Frederick Long - noted as "Paper Box Manufacturer" in 1891 census
of Aurora. North portion of the lot sold to to daughter Ann in 1886 (29
Wells Street). Property purchased by Charles Cosford (occupied at
Underhill-Sisman shoe factory) in 1911.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 255 of 302
Mosley
StreetWells Street
Address: 35 Wells Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 13 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1912
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: American Foursquare
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Poor
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes: Rear window missing, foundation crumbling
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Some integrity has been
compromised. Overall form and window openings remain. Covered
sun room added.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
None
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 256 of 302
Mosley S
t
r
e
e
tWells StreetAddress: 37 Wells Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 13 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1880
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Cottage
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes: Rear addition renovation 2 storeys
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Representative of the Ontario
Gothic Cottage style.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Purchased by Wm. Atkinson
in 1873 for $1,200.00 (1/4 acre), sold to Wm Boynton in 1874,
subsequently sold to Rowland. Purchased by Wm. Wetherell in 1874
(pt lots 13 and 14) for $650.00.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 257 of 302
Wells Street
Mosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 39 Wells Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 13 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1870
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Vernacular (Aurora)
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Some removal of original
attributes and materials.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Land mortgaged by William
Atkinson in 1875 for $600.00 to John Allen. John Allen sold to Jacob
Anderson for $350..0 in 1881. Assessment roll for 1882 indicates Jacob
Anderson as residing on Wells Street. Date of construction of dwelling
inconclusive, but likely in the 1870s or 1880s. J. Anderson was
employed at the Fleury Foundry. Widow of Jacob Anderson sold the
property in 1941. Purchased by David Edward Anderson in 1941, who
was a "moulder".
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 258 of 302
Wells Street
Mosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 43 Wells Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 13 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1874
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Vernacular (Aurora)
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Constructed by William
Atkinson (see LACAC reference). Property purchased by William
Rowland (carpenter) in 1874. Unknown if house was constructed at
this time. Sold two years later to William G. Graham (woodworker at
Fleury Foundry) for $125.00. property owned by Charles Thom
(balcksmith) between 1885 and 1887. Sold to William W Boynton in
1887. House tenanted in the late 19th century. Purchased by Lydia
Cosford in 1903.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 259 of 302
Wells Street
Mosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 47 Wells Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 13 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1874
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Vernacular (Aurora)
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: House constructed by
William Atkinson. Atkinson purchased a number of vacant lots in
1873. Property sold in 1874 to William W. Boynton (carpenter). Family
relocated to Toronto in 1890 and rented to Alfred Redditt (tanner).
House purchased by William H. Watson (shoe mebder) in 1893. W.
Watson died in 1940, sold to Audrey Petrie in 1941.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 260 of 302
Wells Street
Harrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 101 Wells Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 61 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1940s
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Altered (unknown)
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: One and half storey cottage with open
gabled roof, gabled dormer. House has a rear addition and
attached open gable garage. Original window frame at rear of
main house.
Condition Notes: Vinyl siding covering original material, likely wood
frame construction.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
None
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Property is located on lands
originally owned by Herman (also Hermas) E. Proctor who was Irish
and a Postmaster by occupation (also lists army) although he is listed
as living on Young Street not this property. Later owned between
1942-1965 by Mundell Family.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Contextual value is solely in its support
to the overall character of the area.Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1940s
Page 261 of 302
Wells
StreetHarrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 103 Wells Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 62 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1915
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Large addition above original roof gable.
likely new verandah
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Likely constructed c. 1914.
Property rented to William Stoneman, who purchased the property
from the previous owner, Mr Deviney in 1924. William Stoneman was
a pattern maker, possibly at the Sisman shoe factory. Sold to John
and Susie Grimes in 1937.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 262 of 302
Wells
Street
Connau
g
h
t
A
v
e
n
u
e
Harrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 111 Wells Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 65 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1925
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Craftsman
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees in rear yard.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Vacant lot purchased by
Albert Allen Tew in 1926. House likely constructed in 1927. Owned by
the Tews family until 1959 when it was purchased by William George
and Bertha Cameron. Cameron was a shoe worker.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 263 of 302
Wells StreetConnau
g
h
t
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 113 Wells Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 66 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Bungalow
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees. Large and sympathetic
addition along Connaught.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Likely constructed in the
1930s or 1940s (LACAC reference). D.L. and Mrs. D.L Holman (driver)
1957.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1930s
Page 264 of 302
Wellingto
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t
Wells Street
Address: 20 Wells Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 3 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1878
Date Identified/Listed: 1977
Architectural Style/Influence: Altered (unknown)
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: "The Charles house". See attached LACAC
notes regarding specific heritage attributes. Note: Rear additions
and renovated porch dated 1906. Not conclusively determined if
building was designed in either the Italianate or Queen Anne
architectural style (See photos attached).
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Some removal of original features
- parlour window and verandah with turret suggests Queen Anne
style
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Likely constructed by
William Atkinson, who sold to Albert Atkinson. Sold by J. Miller to
Herbert J. Charles in 1906. Remained owned by the Charles family
until 1976. Herbert J. Charles noted as Town Undertaker in 1881
Census of Aurora.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 265 of 302
Well in gton
Street
E
ast
Wells Street
Address: 24 Wells Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 2 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1860
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Georgian
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Building has lost some important
heritage attributes - building retains overall scale, massing, and
window openings (3-bay). Building is early within its context.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1860s
Page 266 of 302
Wells StreetAddress: 28 Wells Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 1 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: Bet. 1913-1927
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
None
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 267 of 302
Metcalfe
S
t
r
e
e
tWells StreetAddress: 68 Wells Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed:
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Altered (unknown)
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Multi unit dwelling. Removal of original
attributes over time. No longer a representative of an architectural
style. Original building dates to the 19th century. Second building
added between 1927 and 1960 as per review of FIPs. See attached
1911 photo of brick building (now clad in siding with additions).
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
None
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century; Property often
referred to as "The Pines" for the mature trees which may have been
planted by George Harrison in the late 19th c.
Major
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Confirmation of a dwelling
located on the property in 1888, owned by George Harrison.
Advertisement in 1889 notes trees "The Pines", "roughcast dwelling",
with stables and outbuildings. Purchased in 1888 by Van Nostrand.
Rented to Thomas Redditt (former principal of Aurora High School) in
1891. Purchased by T. H. Lennox in 1917 (trustee, Lawyer, Councillor,
MP) Converted into apts by Dr. Gunton in 1939. See attachments.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: No
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: Late 19th Century
Page 268 of 302
Wells
S
t
reetHarrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 100 Wells Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 67 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1921
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Craftsman
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees. Wrap around verandah,
gabled dormers soffitting and ionic columns of verandah.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: Yes Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Building likely a Craftsman
building which was altered. Existing curved verandah does not
appear on 1904 rev. 1927 FIP and may have been added later.
Majority of attributes retained.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 269 of 302
Wells StreetConnau
g
h
t
A
v
e
n
u
e
Harrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 104 Wells Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 69 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Arts and Crafts
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: House likely constructed
between 1921 and 1927 for either Eva M. Stephens or Robert R.
Brown. Former residence of Josephine Brown (widow) -1957.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 270 of 302
Harr ison
Avenue
Wells Street
Connaug
h
t
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 108 Wells Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 71 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1915
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Former residence of Reg.
Wood (labourer) and Mrs. Wood - 1957
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 271 of 302
WaltonDriveWellingt
o
n
S treet
E
a
s
t
Larmont StreetAddress: 11 Larmont Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 13 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1910
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 272 of 302
Wellingt
o
n
S treet
E
a
s
t
Larmont StreetAddress: 19 Larmont Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 13 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Altered (unknown)
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
None
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
None
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 20th Century
Page 273 of 302
Berczy StreetLarmont StreetAddress: 25 Larmont Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 5 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1910
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Vernacular (Aurora)
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 274 of 302
Berczy StreetLarmont StreetAddress: 31 Larmont Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 6 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1875
Date Identified/Listed: 1977
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: YesSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century; Associated
with the industrial base and/or development of the Southeast Old
Aurora neighbourhood.
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Planing mill supplied wood
to the surrounding community - providing materials for development.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 275 of 302
Berczy StreetLarmont StreetAddress: 33 Larmont Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 6 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1875
Date Identified/Listed: 1977
Architectural Style/Influence: Ontario Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: George H Phillips house. "Site of Aurora
Planing Mill" Built as a residence in the 1870s by John P. Eakin.
"It is believed that a planing mill was constucted behind the house at
the same time and that both buildings were
soon purchased (on April 4th, 1874) by George H. Phillips and his
brother John A. Phillips."
No features of the former Planing Mill survive. Philips converted the
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: YesSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the industrial base
and/or development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood.
Associated with the historical development of the 1854 Subdivision
by John Mosley (Plan 68) and buildings constructed in the mid. to
late 19th century;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Use of the property as a
Planning Mill (i.e. an activity) supplied the Town with lumber, which
resulted in the ability to construct buildings and develop the Town.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 276 of 302
Mosley
StreetBerczy StreetLarmont StreetAddress: 35 Larmont Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 7 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1912
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: "Quantz McMahon house"
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s):
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 277 of 302
Mosley S
t
r
e
e
tLarmont StreetAddress: 37 Larmont Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 7 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1910
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Stucco possibly original (See 1981 photo).
Valued at $400.00 1901 - possibly indicates construction of a
dwelling. Owned by Mark Browning in 1901 and by Michael Shulman
1910. (Note: 1911 census notes that Mark Browning resided on
Mosley Street) No reference to Shulman found in 1911 census of
Aurora.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Associated with Emma and
Gladys Wythe. Gladys Wythe - stenographer
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 278 of 302
Larmont StreetMosley S
t
r
e
e
t BerczyStreetAddress: 45 Larmont Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 9 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1907
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: "Cockerill McMahon house". Edwardian
with Romanesque and Italianate influences (more unique example)
but not rare. William Cockerill - Salvation Army Officer. Rose Cockerill
- daughter of George Thomas Browning. McMahon - resided here
from 1946 to 1968.
Condition Notes: Painted over quoins and keystone and jack arches
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: Yes Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
None
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1900s
Page 279 of 302
Larmont StreetMosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 49 Larmont Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 10 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1875
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling and Outbuilding
Heritage Attributes Notes: Converted garage is secondary suite and
greenhouse. Front elevation porch re-constructed c. 2015.
Condition Notes: Rear addition and deck system
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 280 of 302
Larmont StreetMosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Address: 63 Larmont Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 20 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1912
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Vernacular (Aurora)
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature tree, "The Blueprint House" (local
reference due to colour and blueprint style drawings and notes
painted onto the exterior of the house)
Condition Notes: Well maintained example of Workers Housing.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Well preserved.
Major
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Land purchased by Hermas
E. Protctor, constructed to provide housing opportunities for those
working locally. Purchased by Dalton Richardson, who sold to Austin
Richardson (1912). Former home of Mrs. William Major, sold to Veta
Ward and Alfred Folliott. Owned by Philip Phillips 1919 (tenanted).
George and Margaret Maginn (1929)
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 281 of 302
Mosley S
t
r
e
e
t
Larmont StreetAddress: 67 Larmont Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 20 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1913
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Vernacular (Aurora)
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature tree
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
None
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 282 of 302
Wellingt
o
n
S
t
r
e
e
t
E
a
s
t
Larmont StreetAddress: 24 Larmont Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 12 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1920
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Altered (unknown)
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Specific architectural style not
readily identifiable. Possibly Craftsman Bungalow.
None
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
None
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 283 of 302
Larmont StreetAddress: 28 Larmont Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 1 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1870
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Ontario Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: "The Donnelly house". Donnelly noted as
Labourer in the 1871 Gazeteer of York County. Donnelley is not
noted in the 1881 Gazeteer.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 284 of 302
Larmont StreetAddress: 32 Larmont Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 2 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1873
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Georgian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Some removal of attributes - style likely
Georgian Cottage or Classical Cottage.
Lot purchased 1873 by Wm Atkinson for 1/4 acre. Purchased by J.E.
McNally in 1874. McNally noted as Drugist in 1891 Census of Aurora.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: Yes
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 285 of 302
Harrison
A
v
e
n
u
e EdwardStreetAddress: 101 Edward Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 1 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1920
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Colonial Revival
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Poor
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Rear yard - mature trees.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the industrial base
and/or development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood;
Associated with the second wave of development of the Southeast
Old Aurora neighbourhood and the former “Rosemount” community
(i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and buildings constructed in this era;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Built by Collis Leather as
workers housing.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Similar to other houses on the street
that were built by Collis Leather.Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 286 of 302
Harrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Edward StreetAddress: 105 Edward Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 3 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1913
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Colonial Revival
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the industrial base
and/or development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood;
Associated with the second wave of development of the Southeast
Old Aurora neighbourhood and the former “Rosemount” community
(i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and buildings constructed in this era;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Built by Collis Leather as
workers housing. Collis leather operated for over 100 years and
contributed to the industrial growth of the Town.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Similar to other houses on the street
that were built by Collis LeatherRecommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 287 of 302
Harrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Edward StreetAddress: 107 Edward Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 4 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1914
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees. Angel stone facade
covering original wood frame
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the industrial base
and/or development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood;
Associated with the second wave of development of the Southeast
Old Aurora neighbourhood and the former “Rosemount” community
(i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and buildings constructed in this era;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Built by Collis Leather as
workers housing.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 288 of 302
Edward StreetHarrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Connaug
h
t
Avenue
Address: 109 Edward Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 5 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1914
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the industrial base
and/or development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood;
Associated with the second wave of development of the Southeast
Old Aurora neighbourhood and the former “Rosemount” community
(i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and buildings constructed in this era;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Built by Collis Leather as
workers housing
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 289 of 302
Edward StreetConnau
g
h
t
A
v
e
n
u
e
Harrison
Avenue
Address: 111 Edward Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 7 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1915
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Edwardian
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees.
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the industrial base
and/or development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood;
Associated with the second wave of development of the Southeast
Old Aurora neighbourhood and the former “Rosemount” community
(i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and buildings constructed in this era;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Walter Collis co-owned/
owned this property, as well as the adjacent 93 acres from May until
September 1912. In August 1912, he purchased land on the other
side of Town.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 290 of 302
Edward StreetHarrison
A
v
e
n
u
e
Connaug
h
t
A
v
e
n
u
e
Address: 104 Edward Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 24 Plan 120
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: 1920
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Worker's Housing
Integrity: Excellent
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Mature trees
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1920s
Page 291 of 302
Wellingto
n
Street
E
a
s
t
Berczy StreetAddress: 26 Berczy Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 4 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: C.1865
Date Identified/Listed: 1986
Architectural Style/Influence: Ontario Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the second wave of
development of the Southeast Old Aurora neighbourhood and the
former “Rosemount” community (i.e. south of Harrison Avenue) and
buildings constructed in this era;
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1860s
Page 292 of 302
Berczy StreetAddress: 32 Berczy Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 6 Plan 68
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1856
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Georgian
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Poor
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Proposed to be demolished. Has been
remodeled from original Georgian style. Alterations include: covered
upper window, replaced windows and door, transom front
entrance, twin chimney's, stucco facade.
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: Yes
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the historical
development of the 1854 Subdivision by John Mosley (Plan 68) and
buildings constructed in the mid. to late 19th century;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Associated with John
Mosely as one of the dwellings forming part of his 1854 subdivision
(Plan 68).
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
None
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Southeast Old Aurora
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1850s
Page 293 of 302
IndustrialParkwaySouthAddress: 45 Industrial Parkway South
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 2 Plan 80
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1910
Date Identified/Listed: N/A
Architectural Style/Influence: Altered (unknown)
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Poor
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Adaptively reused. Likely new board and
batten and wood elements
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Within the Aurora Promenade Secondary Plan Area
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Likely workers housing.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: No
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Building was located in a rural area
and 1970 aerial photo does not indicate it may have been directly
linked to the railway or industrial phase (i.e. physical or historical
connection).
Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Industrial Parkway South/Rail Corridor
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1910s
Page 294 of 302
Yonge StreetAddress: 14086 Yonge Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 1 Plan 132
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Altered (unknown)
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Poor
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: open gables roof with box end eaves,
original craftsman style windows and window openings. Gables
dormer on front elevation.
Condition Notes: Note: Existing features not visible from the street.
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Subject to Town of Aurora Official Plan Amendment No.
34
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Modest 1.5 storey Craftsman
(Craftsman style windows). Building includes features which are not
of the Craftsman style, including return eaves which suggests a Neo-
Classical building.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Part of the former Aurora Gardens
subdivision, assembled by Henry B. Richey and Richard Trimble (c.
1914). Plan 132
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Purchased by John Joseph
Menton and wife and Annie in 1921, may not have resided here until
1928.
Assets transferred to William John Menton in 1948. Married Corine
Mason. W. John Menton active in the Roman Catholic Church,
active member of the Knights of Columbus and establishing the
Aurora Council of the Knights of Columbus. W.J. Menton died 2004.
If house was constructed earlier - possibly by or for J. Wells (1878),
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Aurora Gardens
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: N/A
Page 295 of 302
YongeStreetRidge
R
oad
Address: 40 Ridge Road
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 4 Plan 132
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Period Revival
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Unable to see from road.
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Subject to Town of Aurora Official Plan Amendment No.
34
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Period Revival with Tudor
influences.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Part of the former Aurora Gardens
subdivision, assembled by Henry B. Richey and Richard Trimble (c.
1914).
Minimal
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Aurora Gardens
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: Mid. 20th Century
Page 296 of 302
Address: 114 Ridge Road
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 11 Plan 132
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Bungalow
Integrity: N/A
Current Owner:
Condition: N/A
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Stone building. Features not visible from
the street.
Condition Notes: Integrity and condition unable to be determined -
features not visible from the street.
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Subject to Town of Aurora Official Plan Amendment No.
34
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: NoHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Part of the former Aurora Gardens
subdivision, assembled by Henry B. Richey and Richard Trimble (c.
1914).
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: Aurora Gardens
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: Mid. 20th Century
Page 297 of 302
Wellington Heights CourtMarksbu ry
C
o
u
r
t
Address: 22 Marksbury Court
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 22 Plan 65M2660
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed:
Date Identified/Listed:
Architectural Style/Influence: Ontario Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Ontario cottage, centre hall plan, front
porch
Condition Notes: Brick veneer added in the 1920s and concrete
foundation added.
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): YesUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Early development in the surrounding
area of the Town.
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Property claimed to be
owned by the Appleton Family for over a century who originated
from England. There name shows in the Tremaine Map of 1860
owning a farm at the north-east corner of Bathurst and Yonge Street.
It is also claimed that there were "sawmills, Indian burial grounds and
beaver dams on the property".
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: No
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: Yes
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Historically linked to its surroundings as
it originally was an agricultural property.Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group:
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1840s
Page 298 of 302
Address: 14121 Yonge Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Con 1 Lot 73
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: N/A
Date Identified/Listed: 1988
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes: Gothic Revival Cottage is of potential
CHVI. Other existing outbuildings and sheds are not of CHVI and are
associated with the use of the site as a golf course.
Condition Notes:
Risk: Yes
Risk Notes: Subject to Town of Aurora Official Plan Amendment No.
34
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description: Gothic Revival Cottage, re-clad
with Board and batten.
Moderate
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description:
Minimal
Significant Theme: No
Historical/Associative Value Description: Also known as Beverly Farm.
Formerly the Toronto & North York Hunt Club. 1988 LACAC listing
refers to Gothic Revival Cottage (no other features of potential
CHVI) see 1970 map attached. Former residence of Norman Beverly
(farmer) (b. 1923 d. 2000). Part of Lot 73, Con 1 (Whitchurch), owned
by Jno. Boyd in 1878 (no buildings indicated on the lot). Existing
building likely constructed c.1880s.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
None
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: No
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: Lot has changed considerably, no
longer functions as an agricultural farm complex and has been
adaptively re-used as a Hunting Club and Golf Course.
Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: N/A
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1880s
Page 299 of 302
Leslie StreetAddress: 14421 Leslie Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Con 3
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: Yes
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c.1870
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Cottage
Integrity: Fair
Current Owner:
Condition: Excellent
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: YesSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the theme of early
19th century agricultural settlement;
Major
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description: Associated with the milling
operation which produced the renowned White Rose Flour and
which would have contributed to the centre of community life in the
area.
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Moderate
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description: No longer used as a milling operation.
Residential.Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: N/A
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 300 of 302
Address: 1563 Vandorf Sideroad
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Con 3 Lot 15
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1870
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Cottage
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Dwelling
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the theme of early
agricultural settlement;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: No
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): Yes
Neighbourhood Group: N/A
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 301 of 302
Address: 14897 Leslie Street
AURORA HERITAGE REGISTER REVIEW
PROPERTY EVALUATION SHEET - DRAFT
Heritage Status: Listed
Property Number (PIN):
Map
Legal Description: Lot 18
Designation By-law:
Wood Plaque: No
Ontario Regulation 9/06 Assessment
General Information
Property Description
Date/Era Constructed: c. 1870s
Date Identified/Listed: 1995
Architectural Style/Influence: Gothic Revival
Integrity: Poor
Current Owner:
Condition: Fair
Photo Documentation
Date: April 25, 2022
Contains public sector information made available under The Regional Municipality of York's Open Data License
••
Heritage Attributes: Farm Complex
Heritage Attributes Notes:
Condition Notes:
Risk: No
Risk Notes:
Design/Physical Value:
Rare: No Early (pre-1867): NoUnique: No Representative: YesHigh Degree of Craftsmanship/Artistic Merit: No
High Degree of Technical/Scientific Achievement: No
Design/Physical Value Description:
Minimal
Historical/Associative Value:
Significant Event: No Significant Person: No
Significant Activity: NoSignificant Organization/Institution: No
Significant Theme Description: Associated with the theme of early
19th century agricultural settlement;
Moderate
Significant Theme: Yes
Historical/Associative Value Description:
Contextual Value:
Defines the Character of the Area: No
Minimal
Maintains the Character of the Area: No
Supports the Character of the Area: Yes
Is Important in its Physical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Functional Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Visual Link to its Surroundings: No
Is Important in its Historical Link to its Surroundings: No
Is a Landmark: No
Contextual Value Description:Recommendation
Moderate Value - Remain on the Register,
Meets the Criteria
Mature Tree(s): No
Neighbourhood Group: N/A
Contributes to the Understanding of the Community/Culture: No
Reflects Work/Ideas of a Person Significant to the Community: No
Date Range: 1870s
Page 302 of 302